Alexander Isak has never been short of talent. Sympathy, though? That’s been in far shorter supply.
Liverpool’s £100 million striker arrived under a cloud of resentment, his slow start on Merseyside viewed through the prism of the player revolt at Newcastle that had forced the club’s hand and opened the door to Anfield. When he failed to explode immediately, few were inclined to look kindly on the reasons why.
He had no real pre-season in his legs. No base, no rhythm. The electric, gliding forward who had once been talked about as the closest thing to a Premier League answer to Erling Haaland looked like a pale imitation of that player. The sharp runs were missing, the bursts over five yards dulled. The price tag screamed; the performances whispered.
Then came December 20 at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium. For a fleeting moment, Liverpool saw exactly what they had paid for. Florian Wirtz slipped a through-ball into space, Isak timed his run, opened his body and finished with icy precision. One move, one goal, a glimpse of the terrifying potential of a front line built around two nine-figure signings.
A split-second later, it all shattered.
Micky van de Ven’s reckless challenge clattered into Isak’s left leg, snapping his fibula and silencing the away end. The striker who had just announced himself as Liverpool’s future was suddenly Liverpool’s latest long-term absentee. The club seethed at the tackle; Isak disappeared into months of rehab.
He returned a little over three months later, but never truly escaped the damage. Muscle problems stalked him, each twinge and strain traced back to that missing pre-season. He looked like a man forever chasing his own fitness, never quite catching it. Three league goals in 14 appearances was a miserable return for a player of his calibre and cost.
He needed minutes, not excuses. A stretch of games, not sporadic cameos. What he got instead was a World Cup in North America that, for once, arrived at just the right time.
For Sweden, Isak finally played. And kept playing. He featured in all but one minute of their run to the round of 32, scoring once and directly contributing to four goals. The numbers were decent; the significance was greater. He banked competitive minutes, rediscovered tempo, felt like a centre-forward again instead of a rehab project.
Even so, when the new Premier League season kicked off, doubts lingered. Was he robust enough for Andoni Iraola’s intense, front-foot football? Could he adapt to the demands of a coach who wanted his No.9 to run, press, link, harry – not just finish?
He scored in a 2-2 draw with Nottingham Forest on August 29, but not everyone was buying the resurgence.
“I was at the game,” former Liverpool defender Stephen Warnock told GOAL. “Isak, apart from his goal, did absolutely nothing. He was so poor. He didn't look interested at all.
“And I'm thinking, this is the guy who's meant to have had a proper pre-season, coming back hungry, fit, proving what he can do. And he didn't look like he could.
“He didn't look like he could carry the shirt. And that's a huge problem. It's that weight of expectation of the price tag to deliver.
“He doesn't look at the races at the moment.”
It sounded brutal. It also echoed what many in the stands were thinking. A £100m striker cannot afford to look disinterested, even for a half.
The response came quickly.
The following Friday at Ipswich, Isak dragged Liverpool to their first win of the season, scoring both goals in a 2-0 victory and playing with a conviction that had been missing for far too long. The finishing was sharp, the movement more purposeful. A door creaked open.
Then he refused to let it close. He scored again against Bournemouth. Then Brentford. Then Brighton. Four games, four wins, four more goals. Six in seven league matches, after just three in 14 the previous campaign. The numbers finally matched the billing.
Iraola, though, has never pretended he only wants a poacher.
“He's a striker that if we can put him in the right positions, if we can provide him with crosses and good situations, he will score the goals,” the Liverpool boss said last weekend. But he added a clear caveat after that Ipswich brace.
“It is also about other things. I will demand other things so we can play well, and if we play well, we are in good positions, the goals will come for him.
“So, I think he has to contribute to the collective.”
That remains the challenge. Isak understands the need to defend from the front in Iraola’s system, but his work without the ball can still lag behind that of Lewis Koumas, whose relentless pressing has endeared him to the staff. Cody Gakpo, having laid on several of Isak’s early-season goals, has already joked that the Swede owes him a few assists. It was a light remark with a serious edge: Liverpool’s No.9 still doesn’t do enough in the build-up.
There are signs of progress, though. Bradley Barcola’s arrival has given Isak a partner whose instincts complement his own. The Frenchman’s direct running and sharp delivery have already produced key moments, with Barcola supplying Isak’s decisive goals against both Brentford and Brighton. Those combinations hint at a front line that could become far more than the sum of its expensive parts.
Isak is still not the all-action, all-round menace he was at Newcastle, when he could drift out wide, drop in, or run in behind with equal threat. But in the one area that matters most to a centre-forward, he is starting to look like his old self again. Clinical. Cold. Punishing.
And that is exactly what should concern Mikel Arteta.
Arsenal gambled in the market. They turned away from Isak and instead backed Viktor Gyokeres to be the more economical solution with similar impact. On paper, it made sense: a physically dominant striker from Sporting CP, capable of bullying defenders and running channels, but without the nine-figure fee.
On grass, the story has been harsher. Gyokeres only opened his account for the season in a Carabao Cup humiliation at Fleetwood Town, a night that also underlined the erratic nature of Kai Havertz’s finishing. Arsenal’s attack misfired, their supposed new reference point up front still searching for rhythm and conviction.
Gyokeres offers plenty physically. He runs, he battles, he stretches defences. What he does not do often enough is finish. He misses far more chances than he converts, a flaw that becomes glaring in tight games and high-pressure moments.
Isak is the opposite. He can drift to the fringes of a contest, sometimes to the point of invisibility, but give him one clear sight of goal and he still carries that Haaland-like menace: two touches, one shot, game over. For all the turbulence of the last year, that edge has not dulled.
Liverpool are beginning to lean into that ruthlessness again. Arsenal, staring at the numbers from their own forward line, can only wonder what might have been had they chosen differently.
On Sunday at Anfield, Arteta does not need a lecture on expected goals or pressing triggers. He needs his strikers to finish – and he needs Isak not to remind him, in brutal, clinical fashion, of the one that got away.






