Viktor Gyokeres arrived at the Emirates in 2025 as the big-money solution to a problem Arsenal have been trying to crack for years. The brief was simple: become the ruthless No.9 to turn a slick, possession-heavy side into serial winners on the continent.
On paper, his first season did its job. Twenty-one goals across all competitions is a respectable return for any debut campaign in England. Yet here Arsenal are, deep into another season, and Gyokeres is watching more than he is leading.
One Premier League start. That’s all Mikel Arteta has given him in the current campaign, with Kai Havertz preferred through the middle. Gyokeres has still found the net four times, having opened his account in the Community Shield, but there is no escaping the feeling that he is a supporting act in a role he was signed to own.
Havertz, a roaming, elastic forward, keeps getting the nod. Effective at times, clever between the lines, but not the cold-eyed finisher Arsenal fans have been craving since the days when chances felt like goals, not questions.
And that’s the heart of it. Can this Arsenal side really conquer Europe without a fearsome, fixed-point striker?
Champions League Scars and a Growing Doubt
The doubt comes with scars. Arsenal were a penalty kick away from lifting the Champions League last season, only to suffer shootout heartbreak against PSG in the 2026 final. They had gone toe-to-toe with one of Europe’s heavyweights, yet the old debate resurfaced as soon as the dust settled: are they still one elite No.9 short?
PSG themselves offer a provocative counter-argument. Luis Enrique has embraced a system built on movement and fluidity rather than a traditional spearhead. Ousmane Dembele, Desire Doue, Khvicha Kvaratskhelia – they glide, drift, and interchange, pulling defences apart without a classic centre-forward anchoring the attack.
Barcelona did it under Pep Guardiola. False nines, rotating front lines, goals from everywhere. Even now, the Catalans often line up without a recognised central striker.
So could Arsenal follow that path all the way to the top of Europe?
For William Gallas, the answer is blunt.
Gallas: “Only PSG Can Get Away With It”
The former Arsenal defender, speaking to GOAL in association with SeatPick, did not dress it up.
“I think it's only PSG who can play without a striker,” Gallas said. “They’re the only team that can still win games and win the Champions League without a striker. Luis Enrique has played without a striker who is a real number nine for many years so he conducts that system perfectly.
“For Arsenal and Mikel Arteta, I think he really needs that number nine who can help him win these important games and score that important goal and right now, it looks like they don't have that number nine.”
That is a sharp verdict on a squad that currently sits five points clear at the top of the Premier League and carries the title of defending champions. Domestically, Arsenal look powerful, organised and confident. They control games, strangle space, and suffocate opponents.
But Gallas is talking about the very top level. The nights when one chance decides everything. The kind of moment that slipped through their fingers against PSG.
Arteta has built a side that spreads responsibility. Goals come from wide, from midfield, from late runners. Yet in the tightest games, the former France international believes Arsenal still lack that one player whose presence alone tilts the contest.
Fixture Load, Frustration and a Manager’s Balancing Act
The schedule, at least, offers Arteta room to experiment. Arsenal are fighting on multiple fronts again. They remain unbeaten in Europe this season, with heavyweight clashes against Borussia Dortmund and Real Madrid looming on the horizon. Another FA Cup campaign awaits in 2027.
But one avenue to minutes has already closed. The Carabao Cup exit to League Two side Fleetwood was a shock on the pitch and a problem off it.
For squad players like Gyokeres, those early-round domestic cup ties are oxygen. A chance to feel central, not peripheral. A chance to remind the manager, and themselves, that they belong in the conversation.
Gallas knows what happens when that oxygen disappears.
“Unfortunately, Arsenal are out of the Carabao Cup now and that can be a good competition to make players happy, to make players feel that they are part of the project, because we know at the beginning of the season, everybody is very excited to fight for their position,” he said.
“Slowly, slowly, when you are fighting, when you are training very hard, and then on the weekend you are not in the starting eleven or you are not on the list for the weekend, slowly, slowly your excitement starts to drop.
“This is especially true in the winter period of November and December and January, you suddenly as a player you are not the same. You go to training but not really with the same motivation because before you even set foot on the training ground, you almost know you won't be in the starting XI for the weekend or you won't be on the list. That is very difficult sometimes for the players.”
The warning is clear. A long season can turn heavy for those stuck on the fringes. The energy that drives a title defence and a European push does not just come from the starting XI; it comes from a squad that feels involved, alive, ready.
Gallas, though, still sees a manager equipped to handle that storm.
“That's why they have to be really, really strong and Mikel Arteta, he knows how to communicate with his players, to keep their seasons alive.”
The No.9 Dilemma That Could Define the Season
So the picture is set. Arsenal, champions of England, five points clear. Unbeaten in Europe. A manager trusted to manage egos, emotions and expectations.
And yet, right at the centre of the pitch, the question refuses to go away.
Is Gyokeres the answer, waiting for a run of games to prove it? Is Havertz the long-term solution as a roaming forward in a system that leans into fluidity over tradition? Or, as Gallas insists, will Arsenal’s Champions League dream continue to hang on the absence of a ruthless, undeniable No.9?
The fixtures against Dortmund and Real Madrid will not just test Arsenal’s credentials. They may reveal whether this beautifully constructed side can defy convention in Europe – or whether, in the end, the old truth still holds: titles might be shared, but the biggest nights often belong to the striker who finishes them.






