Benjamin Lundt Shines as St. Louis CITY Claims First U.S. Open Cup Title in Penalty Shootout
Reserve goalkeeper Benjamin Lundt emerged as the hero in the U.S. Open Cup final, helping St. Louis CITY defeat Columbus Crew on penalties. His performance brought excitement to an otherwise uneventful match and highlighted the club’s emphasis on process over immediate results.
Match Overview
For much of the game, Columbus Crew pressured St. Louis CITY, dominating play for nearly 70 minutes. This was unexpected given coach Yoann Damet’s style, which favors ball control rather than constant defending. Despite this, St. Louis held firm. Later, the roles reversed as Columbus became more defensive while St. Louis showed signs of attack.
The match ultimately went to penalties. Lundt, who replaced injured starter Roman Burki, saved two shots, helping St. Louis score all five of their penalties. The victory secured the club’s first trophy and could mark the start of a successful era for the city’s soccer scene.
Key Observations
- St. Louis CITY missed star forward Rafa Navarro, which limited their offensive options.
- Columbus Crew lacked finishing power despite controlling many shots—only three were on target.
- The game ended as a hard-fought battle with many stoppages and no goals in regular or extra time.
Winners and Losers
Winner: Yoann Damet
Damet has transformed St. Louis CITY in his first full season as head coach. He focuses on gradual improvement and teamwork rather than individual stars. This trophy is a significant achievement for a team that seemed unlikely to claim such honors six months ago. Damet’s philosophy paid off as he guided the club to a historic moment.
Loser: Laurent Courtois
Serving as interim manager, Courtois managed to reach the final despite missing key players like Wissam Abou Ali due to injury. His team showed grit, and his tactics created chances, but the lack of a reliable finisher cost Columbus dearly. While his coaching record shows promise, this night wasn’t his breakthrough.
Winner: Benjamin Lundt
Lundt stepped in after Burki’s injury and played a crucial role during the shootout. Though not flashy or modern in his approach, relying mostly on instinct, Lundt saved two penalties. His calm presence was decisive in securing the title for St. Louis.
Loser: Rafa Navarro
Navarro was cup-tied and unable to participate. The club paid $12 million for him mid-season due to his goal-scoring prowess, netting eight goals in eight MLS games. His absence left St. Louis lacking a sharp finisher, a gap felt keenly in this match where chances were scarce.
Winner: Wilfried Nancy
Though not coaching either team now, Nancy’s influence remains strong. Laurent Courtois was part of Nancy’s coaching staff at Columbus Next Pro, and St. Louis Sporting Director Core Wray worked closely with Nancy. Both teams mirrored aspects of Nancy’s style, focusing on possession and structure, even if the attacking flair was missing here.
Loser: The Fans
This final was difficult to watch. Few shots on target and a lack of clear scoring chances made it feel like a tactical stalemate rather than an exciting contest. MLS usually offers chaotic, high-scoring games, but this one was slow and cautious, leaving supporters wanting more.






