logo

Michael Carrick or Eddie Howe: Who Should Lead Manchester United?

With uncertainty swirling around Old Trafford and talk of a managerial change, speculation grows that Eddie Howe might replace Michael Carrick as Manchester United’s boss. Paul Parker, a former Premier League winner with United, shared his thoughts with GOAL on who the club should trust to steer the Red Devils forward.

Carrick's Early Impact as Interim Manager

After Ruben Amorim was dismissed, caretaker coach Darren Fletcher handed over the reins to Carrick in mid-January. The former player, who enjoyed major success during his time at United, quickly made his mark by securing a derby win against Manchester City followed by a victory at Arsenal, then on course to be champions.

Contract and Current Challenges

Though Carrick signed a two-year deal and led the team to a third-place finish last season, the summer transfer window saw limited activity, leaving United short in some areas. This season has been tough: just two wins from nine matches across all competitions and no victories in the last five games have fans and board members worried.

Pressure mounts for swift action as United’s hierarchy eyes potential replacements. Eddie Howe, who recently parted ways with Newcastle after nearly five years, is rumored to be on their radar. However, his availability might not last long.

Parker's Take: Stay with Carrick

“I still think you’d stay with Carrick. I’m no expert, but looking at Howe’s situation, after everything he faced with his previous employers, would he want to step into something very similar? He knows he won’t be able to spend what he wants or bring in his own staff. The club’s current setup isn’t made for someone ambitious,” Parker said.
“If you want to be a manager at Manchester United and win the league, that becomes your legacy. But right now, that just can’t happen because of the state of the club and what you’re working with. The buying and selling of players is poor; the club struggles to move players on, and some seem content to just stay put.”
“Eddie needs to make sure his next role fits him perfectly. He’ll want to work for people who share his ambitions. At United, everyone expects to compete for the title, but currently, you won’t get the full backing needed. The team wasn’t seen as contenders at the start of this season or the last, and many underestimated the real situation.”

Current State of Manchester United

The Red Devils haven’t claimed the Premier League since Sir Alex Ferguson retired in 2013 and face numerous issues both on and off the pitch. They were eliminated from the Carabao Cup early and sit 13th in the league after six matches, earning only six points. Their latest defeat came in the Champions League against Atletico Madrid, a game marked by a red card for Leny Yoro and post-match frustration from Lisandro Martinez.

Carrick remains under pressure as Manchester United prepare for an important away match against Leeds United at Elland Road on Sunday.

Upcoming Match

  • Competition: Premier League
  • Date: 18 October 2026
  • Kickoff: 16:00
  • Fixture: Leeds United vs Manchester United