Enzo Maresca walked into the City Ground press room looking less angry than faintly offended, as if football itself had broken an unspoken agreement. His side, perfect for seven league games, have now lost three in a row. That run – seven wins followed by three defeats – has happened only once before in the English top flight, more than a century ago with Sheffield Wednesday in 1904-05.
Maresca’s verdict was that each defeat was different. The numbers back him up in one sense. They also expose a deeper problem he can no longer ignore.
Possession kings, scoreboard losers
At Aston Villa, City had 63% of the ball and racked up 15 attempts to Villa’s eight. They still lost 2-1.
Against Brighton at home, it was even more pronounced: 62% possession, 21 shots to seven. They lost 1-0.
At Nottingham Forest, the dominance became absurd. Seventy-nine percent of the ball, 12 efforts to Forest’s 11. They lost again.
On the surface, Maresca can point to the metrics and claim misfortune. City have the ball, they create chances, they push teams back. Forest, for their part, could reasonably counter with their own numbers: they went into the game third in the league for expected goals but second-bottom for actual goals scored. At some point, that gap was always going to close.
The real concern lies elsewhere.
A high line, and a soft underbelly
City have not kept a clean sheet since their win at Anfield immediately after the last international break. That was nine games ago. The match before Anfield, they conceded three against Sunderland. Seventeen goals against in their last eight games tells its own story.
Three of those goals can be traced, at least partially, to individual errors from Gianluigi Donnarumma. That might explain a few bad moments. It does not explain the pattern.
The pattern is structural. Maresca’s City, like his Leicester and Chelsea before them, live on the edge with an aggressive, high defensive line. To make that work, you need ferocious duels and immediate pressure on the ball. Lose it, and the back four is suddenly staring at grass and runners.
Forest saw the space and sprinted into it. City’s vulnerability in transition was not some new revelation; it was a familiar flaw ruthlessly targeted. Maresca’s teams have often been accused of being overly cautious in possession, recycling the ball and waiting for the perfect angle. It is not conservatism for its own sake. It is insurance. When you defend 40 yards from your own goal, every turnover is a potential catastrophe.
At the City Ground, the insurance failed. Maresca looked genuinely dismayed at how often his players lost their individual battles in the first half. Every time City were stripped of the ball, Forest’s forwards had a clear run at a high line with acres behind it. That is dangerous against any Premier League striker. Against a Liam Delap rediscovering his edge and eager to make up for a wasted year, it is reckless.
A brilliant midfield, built on sand
The selection in midfield only heightened the risk. Maresca has nailed his colours to Enzo Fernández. City paid £125m to prise him from Chelsea, a fee that underlines how highly the coach rates him. On the ball, the Argentinian is everything Maresca wants: press-resistant, incisive, brave.
What he is not, by Premier League standards, is physically imposing.
At Chelsea, when Fernández and Cole Palmer shared a midfield, the side often looked light in the duels. Maresca still found ways to fit him in, even if it meant contorted solutions like using Malo Gusto as a hybrid right-back/No 10 to balance the structure.
The same tension is emerging at City. Rayan Cherki is an outrageously talented attacking midfielder, capable of unlocking defences with a single touch. But Cherki cannot be trusted as a defensive presence. His positioning drifts, his tracking is inconsistent, and physically he can be overpowered. Pep Guardiola recognised those limitations last season.
That is manageable if you build the right platform behind him: two energetic runners, one shuttling box-to-box in the Elliot Anderson mould, another sitting deeper in the Rodri role, screening and cleaning up.
Rodri is gone. Fernández is in. Anderson is suddenly carrying far more of the physical burden than his game really allows. If he is bypassed by a quick break, or if a defender coughs up the ball in a bad area, the whole structure collapses. Within seconds, City are exposed, with a technical but lightweight midfield chasing shadows and a high line braced for the worst.
The problem is not that Fernández and Cherki are bad players. It is that playing them together, in this system, asks the rest of the team to do too much.
Time to rethink – on and off the pitch
Maresca has welcomed this international break as a chance to step back. For once, he admitted, it is better not to have a game immediately after a defeat. The temptation after three losses in a row is to demand a quick response. He prefers a reset.
He has tactical decisions to make. There may be a clever tweak that lets him keep Fernández and Cherki on the pitch without leaving his back four so brutally exposed. There may not. The blunt answer might simply be: stop picking them together.
But Maresca’s problems are not confined to the white lines.
During the last international window, an independent panel found City guilty of all but one of the charges brought by the Premier League. The verdict landed like a thunderclap over the club’s season. There is a growing belief that sanctions – potentially severe, potentially season-defining – could be announced during this break.
Nobody can say with certainty how that kind of looming punishment seeps into a dressing room. At first, it can galvanise. Siege mentality, backs to the wall, us against the world. Over time, defiance can fade into resignation. When players start to feel that the table might be ripped up by lawyers and panels rather than decided by their work on the pitch, intensity drops by a fraction. Duels are lost. Runs are not quite made. The press is half a step late.
So yes, Maresca has a tactical puzzle to solve: the high line, the transitions, the balance in midfield. But the cloud over City is darker than an out-of-form striker or a misfiring press. By the time the Premier League resumes, this could be a team not just slipping out of a title race, but staring at a very different fight altogether.






