Danny Mills has shared his thoughts with GOAL on why removing Manchester City's titles and medals amid their extensive Financial Fair Play (FFP) case would serve little purpose. The former defender sees such punishments as meaningless since memories of those victories are already part of football history.
Overview of the Charges Against Man City
The club faces allegations of misleading financial dealings from 2010 to 2018. An independent commission upheld all but one of the 115 charges brought against them, with a final decision expected by January 2027. Speculation about potential penalties ranges from relegation or large point deductions to transfer bans and heavy fines. Some even suggest erasing every trophy won during this era of dominance.
Manchester City's Trophy Haul Since 2010
- FA Cup: 2011, plus three more since then
- Premier League Titles: Eight
- Champions League: One
- League Cups: Seven
- UEFA Super Cup: One
- FIFA Club World Cup: One
Much of this success came under coach Pep Guardiola, including a historic Treble in the 2022-23 season. Despite the legal challenges, Man City continue to deny wrongdoing and aim to clear their name, though no inquiry has yet covered events beyond 2018.
Mills Explains Why Retroactive Punishments Lack Impact
Speaking with GOAL thanks to Gambling.com, Mills said the situation is complex. He pointed out that financial benefits before 2018 created a foundation for subsequent successes. Drawing a clear line between past violations and later achievements is difficult.
"You can take titles away, irrelevant. You can take medals and trophies away from players, irrelevant. They’ve had those moments, they’ve had those days out, they’ve had those bonuses. You’ve had all the upside of that for a number of years."
Mills compared it to his own experience, joking that if anyone wanted his Carling Cup medal from 2004, they could try to take it, but the fact remains he won it. He suggested that retroactive punishment decades later is similarly pointless.
"It would be like going back now and saying, ‘well, 1966, the ball didn’t cross the line, therefore England didn’t win the World Cup’. Sadly, it’s only, I think, Sir Geoff Hurst that’s still alive now. 50-odd years, it’s kind of irrelevant."
He concluded that while retrospective penalties are tricky, the real challenge lies in deciding how to deal with the club moving forward.
Ongoing Legal Process and Future Focus
Manchester City have yet to learn their ultimate fate and contest many charges. The legal process continues with arguments against harsh sanctions. Meanwhile, manager Enzo Maresca and the squad concentrate on current competitions, including an upcoming Premier League clash against rivals Liverpool on October 11, 2026.






