Jason Wilcox has identified Eddie Howe as his leading candidate to replace Michael Carrick at Manchester United, with two other names effectively struck from the shortlist despite ticking the right boxes.
Carrick’s position has rarely looked more fragile. United have lost five of their first 11 games in all competitions, but it was the 4-1 humiliation at Como on Wednesday that ripped the veneer off the project. A debutant Champions League side from Serie A didn’t just beat United; they dismantled them. The performance was bad enough. What followed made it worse.
Bruno Fernandes, the club captain, broke ranks and publicly questioned Carrick’s tactics. The dressing-room code cracked in full view, and the fallout has been brutal. Pundits have queued up to hammer the midfielder, with Wayne Rooney going in particularly hard, labelling Fernandes and Lisandro Martinez – who had already taken aim at technical director Jason Wilcox last week – as “selfish babies”.
This is the backdrop to Carrick’s fight for survival. Despite heavy speculation he might not even see out the week, United have confirmed he will lead the team against Bournemouth on Sunday and front the media on Friday afternoon.
Behind that show of continuity, the power lines at Old Trafford are humming.
The Athletic reported that Wilcox, for now, is still backing Carrick. But co-owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe looms over the situation and could yet overrule his director of football, with the billionaire leaning on data and AI models to help shape the choice of the next United manager. It is a very modern way to make a very old kind of decision.
Wilcox, though, is not waiting to be caught cold if Carrick’s position collapses. According to talkSPORT’s chief football correspondent Alex Crook, the technical director is now “leaning towards Eddie Howe” as his preferred successor.
Howe is not a new name in the corridors of power at Old Trafford. Under former sporting director Dan Ashworth, United seriously considered the then Newcastle United boss as a replacement for Erik ten Hag, only to turn towards Ruben Amorim in the end. The admiration never quite went away.
Inside the current structure, there is not complete agreement. Director of recruitment Christopher Vivell is understood to be pushing hard for Julian Nagelsmann, seeing the German as the ideal long-term architect. Wilcox, however, is said to favour Howe for one clear reason: his body of work in the Premier League. In a club still scarred by missteps, that experience carries weight, and Wilcox’s voice is expected to resonate more strongly with Ratcliffe and the Glazer family.
Howe has been out of work since leaving Newcastle in the summer. Reports have suggested he wanted a longer break from the touchline, time to reset after the intensity of the job on Tyneside. Yet the calculation changes when the phone call comes from Manchester United. The feeling around the game is that he would be interested if the vacancy formally opened.
Two other managers sit in an awkward middle ground: admired but effectively out of reach. Unai Emery and Fabian Hürzeler both “fit Wilcox’s criteria”, but the practical barriers are stark. Emery would be extremely expensive to lure away from Aston Villa, where he has built a serious contender and holds a powerful position. Hürzeler, meanwhile, is content at Brighton and, at this stage, has no intention of walking away for United.
So Carrick prepares for Bournemouth under the brightest of spotlights, knowing that a preferred successor has already emerged and that patience at the top of the club is thinning. The next 90 minutes at Old Trafford will not just be about three points. They could decide whether this is a blip in a long tenure or the final act before a new man, very possibly Eddie Howe, is asked to pick up the pieces.






