Eddie Howe has moved to the front of Manchester United’s managerial shortlist, with director of football Jason Wilcox viewing the former Newcastle head coach as his preferred successor to Michael Carrick if the club decide to make a change.
Wilcox is understood to be strongly in favour of Howe, convinced that his deep Premier League experience and recent track record at the top end of the division place him ahead of the other candidates under consideration.
Howe walked away from Newcastle in late July, choosing to step back from the game. That break would not rule him out of Old Trafford. Far from it. He would seriously consider returning to the dugout for United if an offer landed on the table.
Cost is another factor. Howe is currently unattached, which makes him a significantly cheaper option than Unai Emery, who is also admired within the club. Any move for Emery would require United to pay Aston Villa around £20m in compensation, a figure that instantly complicates his candidacy.
A CV built for the Premier League spotlight
Howe’s body of work at Newcastle carries real weight in this discussion. Across five years at St James’ Park, he transformed a side drifting towards crisis into a team collecting silverware and returning to Europe’s elite stage.
Taking over from Steve Bruce in November 2021, with Newcastle winless in their first 14 league matches of the season, Howe dragged them clear of trouble and into mid-table. They finished 11th, winning 12 of their final 18 games – a surge that reset expectations on Tyneside.
The momentum did not stop there. In 2023, Howe took Newcastle back into the Champions League for the first time in 20 years. Two seasons later, he repeated the feat and secured qualification again, confirming that their return to Europe’s top competition was no one-off.
The high point came in 2025, when he delivered the Carabao Cup and ended a 70-year wait for a domestic trophy. For a club starved of success, that mattered. It also underlined Howe’s ability to manage pressure and navigate a cup run to its conclusion.
Before Newcastle, he had already logged five seasons in the Premier League with Bournemouth from 2015, guiding a modest club into the top flight and keeping them there against the odds. That accumulated experience – survival fights, European pushes, cup finals – is exactly what appeals to Wilcox as he weighs up United’s future.
Nagelsmann admired, but Wilcox holds the key
Inside Old Trafford’s football structure, Howe is not the only name with powerful backing. Julian Nagelsmann, the former Germany and Bayern Munich coach, is highly regarded by Christopher Vivell, United’s head of recruitment. Vivell sees Nagelsmann as a modern, tactically sharp operator who fits the profile of a long-term project coach.
Yet Wilcox’s stance could prove decisive. Sir Jim Ratcliffe, who now controls football policy at United, is expected to lean heavily on his director of football’s judgement. If Wilcox continues to push Howe as the leading option, that endorsement may carry more weight than any alternative internal recommendation.
Carrick clings on as pressure mounts
All of this unfolds against a bleak backdrop for Michael Carrick. The 45-year-old is under intense scrutiny after overseeing United’s poorest start to a season since 1986. Two wins from 11 games have left his position in serious jeopardy and sharpened the debate over whether the club must act sooner rather than later.
For now, Carrick stays in the dugout. He is expected to remain in charge for Sunday’s visit of Bournemouth and is scheduled to hold his pre-match media conference on Friday. Those commitments underline the club’s desire to avoid a knee-jerk dismissal, but they do not disguise the reality: his job hangs in the balance.
One bad result can change everything. United’s hierarchy know that. So does Carrick.
A giant stadium vision amid the uncertainty
While the manager’s future dominates the football conversation, United are also pushing ahead with a project that will shape the club for decades – the proposed new 100,000-seat stadium.
The club have begun inviting supporters to give their views on the design through a detailed survey. It will go out to season-ticket holders, cup season-ticket holders, executive club members, official members, fans who have bought hospitality at Old Trafford in the last three years, and those on the season-ticket waiting list.
A vast new arena, a reset in the dugout, and a director of football championing Eddie Howe as the man to lead a new era. The decisions United make in the coming weeks will reveal whether this is just another moment of turbulence – or the start of a fundamental rebuild.






