logo

Enzo Maresca Faces Challenges After Strong Start at Manchester City

Enzo Maresca finally has something he has barely tasted since walking into Manchester City in the summer: time.

The international break arrives with City wobbling, the early-season shine dulled by a run of three straight league defeats and a six-point gap to leaders Arsenal. The Italian’s record-breaking seven wins to open the campaign now feel like a different season entirely.

From flawless to fragile in the space of a fortnight.

A perfect start, then the drop

Maresca’s opening act could hardly have been smoother. Seven consecutive Premier League victories, a seamless handover from Pep Guardiola, and City perched serenely at the top of the table. The new man, the new shape, the same old dominance.

Now they sit third, behind Arsenal and Brighton, with questions swirling not just about results, but about the foundations beneath them.

The backdrop is impossible to ignore. In September, City were found guilty of breaking the Premier League’s financial rules. The club have appealed, matches have carried on, but the verdict hangs over everything. No one inside the dressing room knows what the final punishment will look like or when it will land.

Renowned sports psychologist Dr Paul McCarthy, who has worked for 25 years with leading clubs in England, Scotland, Germany and France, has seen this kind of storm before.

“Players are like everyone else – they talk about what is going on in their own lives and things that are topical, especially about uncertain events,” he told BBC Sport. Those conversations, he says, can slowly chip away at what he calls “collective efficacy” – the shared belief in a squad’s ability to do what it needs to do to win.

City had that belief in abundance during their perfect start. Consecutive defeats test it. Three in a row shake it.

McCarthy is blunt about the psychological weight of the ongoing appeal.

Asked if the uncertainty may affect focus and attention, he replied: “Yeah, that would be a very reasonable human response.

“When people are uncertain about their future, that uncertainty leads to a lack of perceived control, so uncertainty is often more stressful than bad news and the research shows that.”

Players still train, still play, still front up. But the biggest storyline at their club sits completely outside their control. That imbalance rarely comes without a cost.

Errors creeping in, numbers turning ugly

The numbers tell their own story.

In the first seven league games of the season, City did not concede a single goal caused by an individual error. Not one. The structure held, the details were sharp, the machine purred.

Across the past three matches, that calm has vanished. Four individual mistakes have directly contributed to goals. City have conceded 13 times in 10 league games – their worst defensive record at this stage since 2008-09, when they had already let in 16.

The guilty verdict arrived during the last international break. City’s immediate response looked reassuring enough: a gritty win over 10-man Liverpool at Anfield, then a narrow victory over Ipswich at Etihad Stadium. The noise off the pitch stayed loud, but the results on it stayed clean.

Then came Aston Villa. Then Brighton. Then Nottingham Forest. Three defeats, the back line repeatedly exposed, and the aura of control punctured by unforced errors.

McCarthy’s “jigsaw” analogy fits here. He talks about piecing together both the personal and professional lives of players to understand performance. When too many pieces move at once – uncertainty over sanctions, tactical tweaks, key departures – the picture blurs.

Maresca’s 3-1-6 and the exposed middle

Maresca is not hiding behind the psychology. His tactical choices are bold, clear and, right now, under the microscope.

While at Chelsea, in a video for NBC Sports, he broke down his preference for evolving counters into a 3-2-2-3, then pushing one player higher to create a 3-1-6. Against Inter Milan, he used that six-man front line to overload a back five.

At City this season, that 3-1-6 has become a more permanent feature. One holding midfielder sacrificed for an extra attacking midfielder. More bodies high, more threat, more risk.

With the calibre of footballers at his disposal, there is a certain logic in going on the front foot and staying there. But any system, however clever on the tactics board, lives or dies by the players asked to execute it.

The tension sits squarely in midfield.

Anderson’s education in the Rodri role

The biggest questions hover around Elliot Anderson and those alongside him.

Anderson is not a natural sitter. He is a roaming midfielder by instinct, one who thrives on his physical edge. At Nottingham Forest he defended with intensity, pressed high and wide, and broke forward to support attacks. His game is about action, not anchoring.

Maresca and his staff have asked him to become something else.

With Rodri leaving in the summer, City lost the metronome at the base of their midfield. The solution, for now, has been to mould Anderson into that deeper role. It is a long-term education; even Rodri needed time to grow into it when he first arrived.

There is nothing inherently wrong with coaching a player into a new, central position. But the cost is visible. City have looked increasingly open through the middle in recent weeks.

Anderson has largely impressed. His energy and aggression remain assets. Yet he often reverts to habit: stepping out of the holding zone to press, to track, to win the ball back. Clever opponents have spotted the pattern, dragging him out, then threading passes into the space he leaves behind.

For Maresca, the root problem lies a step earlier.

After the defeat to Forest, he cut to the heart of it: “You concede transitions when you lose the ball, and when you don’t win duels.” The shape only looks reckless when possession is turned over cheaply and the first challenges are lost.

Right now, that is happening too often.

A back line under strain, and missing ball-players

Behind Anderson, the questions keep coming.

Gianluigi Donnarumma is an outstanding shot-stopper, but he is not known for his ability with the ball at his feet. The defenders in front of him are capable enough in possession, yet this season they have cracked under pressure when playing out from the back, gifting chances and, increasingly, goals.

Guardiola saw a similar tension last season and solved it by shifting more responsibility onto his midfielders. Rodri and, crucially, Bernardo Silva would drop deep, take the ball from the edge of their own box and carry or pass City into midfield almost single-handedly.

Remove that release valve and the flaws look harsher.

Rodri’s departure stripped away the primary shield. The absence of Bernardo Silva, who so often glided back to help City escape the press and build calmly, has made the problem glaring. The ball no longer travels from back to front with the same ease or security.

Anderson, for all his qualities, is not that kind of player. He cannot yet orchestrate the build-up on his own the way Bernardo did. The hope inside the club may rest partly on Ayyoub Bouaddi, who showed flashes of that ability against Brazil’s press at the World Cup – dropping deep, demanding the ball, threading his way out of tight spaces.

Whether Maresca leans on Bouaddi more heavily after the break will be one of the most intriguing calls of his early reign.

The jigsaw, as McCarthy would put it, lies scattered across psychology, tactics and personnel. Maresca now has a rare window to start putting those pieces back together.

The question is not whether City can respond. It is how quickly they can rediscover the collective certainty that once made them feel untouchable.