Thierno Barry walked off Hill Dickinson grinning, and with good reason. Ten goals for the season, another match ball under his arm in all but name, and the sound of Everton’s home crowd still ringing in his ears. Coventry had pushed them, really pushed them, yet the night ended with Barry at the heart of everything – on the scoresheet, in the headlines and right in the middle of a VAR storm.
This was not a comfortable 3-1. It was a Premier League grind, jagged and controversial, the sort of evening where managers leave replay rooms fuming and strikers leave talking about Golden Boots.
Barry catches fire
Barry’s summer graft is starting to look like one of the stories of Everton’s season. He spoke afterwards about long hours of work, about watching Erling Haaland clips and trying to copy the movement, the aggression, the relentlessness. It shows.
He missed chances earlier in the campaign. Plenty of them. The kind that can eat away at a forward’s confidence. “Sometimes it is difficult when you miss a lot of chances, your mind is sometimes bad,” he admitted. But he kept swinging. Now the numbers are catching up with the performances.
Against Coventry he struck twice, the second goal the one that will be replayed from every angle. The ball appeared to brush his arm before flying in, the kind of incident that has seen goals ruled out already this season. This time, after a long look, VAR let it stand. Barry didn’t flinch. David Moyes backed him. Frank Lampard did not.
What nobody could argue with was his impact. Everton had gone behind to what Moyes called a “really poor goal”, the sort that turns an edgy home crowd nervous. Barry dragged them out of it. His movement stretched Coventry, his finishing finally matched his running, and his belief never dipped.
He even found time for a TikTok-inspired celebration, a solo dance he had planned to share with Tyrique George. George bailed. Barry didn’t. That felt about right for the night he was having.
Moyes gets the result, if not the control
Moyes cut a pragmatic figure. He has been around long enough to know when his side has been in a game and when they have controlled one. This was the former.
“I wasn’t quite so sure about a good performance,” he admitted. “We got a performance and we got a result but I have to say Coventry made it really difficult for us.” He’s right. Coventry were bold, direct, and organised. They’ve already beaten Nottingham Forest and Sunderland recently; there is nothing apologetic about the way they approach these fixtures.
Everton’s reaction to falling behind pleased him more than anything. The response was sharp, urgent, and for the final half-hour they played with a tempo Coventry simply couldn’t live with. Barry’s goals mattered, but so did the mentality Moyes has been trying to build.
“He’s becoming an important piece for us,” the manager said of his striker. Ten goals already, a growing presence in the dressing room and, as Moyes joked, a licence now to “smile at me and say I told you so.”
Questions about Jack Grealish’s return drew a short answer. “No more detail at the moment.” Everything else, for now, revolves around those who are fit and firing.
Dewsbury-Hall drives the engine
If Barry finished it, Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall powered it. Three games in a week, three wins, and a midfielder playing like a man with a point to prove.
He called it a “fantastic week” and it has been. His role – that hybrid, free-roaming brief Moyes has handed him – suits his energy and intelligence. He pops up between the lines, drifts wide, drops in, then suddenly appears on the edge of the box. Coventry struggled to track him once Everton clicked into gear.
Their goal, he said, “kicked us into gear – which shouldn’t happen really, but it did”. From there, Everton surged. The last half-hour belonged to them. Coventry “couldn’t deal with it”.
Dewsbury-Hall has his own subplot running in the background. Left out of the latest England squad, he didn’t hide the sting. “It was a disappointing morning, I’m not going to lie,” he said. The dream of playing for his country is still burning. The response – another high-level display – will not have gone unnoticed.
He spoke warmly about Barry too. “He’s come back from the summer like a different player,” he said, delighted that the striker’s finishing finally matched the work he sees every day. On nights like this, the partnership looked like something Everton can build around.
Coventry’s anger boils over
On the other side of the corridor, Lampard was seething. Not with his players. With the decisions.
“Big decisions affected the game, clearly,” he said, and it was hard to argue that Coventry did not have a case. Three major VAR calls, all of them went Everton’s way. It felt like a long, slow accumulation of frustration.
First came the James Tarkowski hair pull on Caleb Yirenkyi just before half-time. The laws on hair pulling were relaxed this season, with the threshold for a red card raised to incidents with excessive force. But for a penalty, the question is simpler: is it a foul? Coventry felt it was. Lampard felt it was. Many watching agreed.
Then came the Taiwo Awoniyi incident early in the second half. Vitalii Mykolenko clipped him near the edge of the area. One angle suggested contact inside the box, another put it right on the line. VAR sided with the latter. No penalty, no free-kick. Coventry got nothing.
Finally, Barry’s second goal. The ball appeared to change direction as it brushed his arm before crossing the line. Earlier this season, Nottingham Forest saw a goal chalked off against Tottenham for something similar. This time, VAR said there was no conclusive proof. Goal given.
Lampard insisted he had seen “a conclusive angle”. Dale Johnson, analysing the incidents, argued Coventry could “feel aggrieved about two of them” at least. Jamie Redknapp called both penalty shouts – the hair pull and the Awoniyi challenge – ones that “should have been a penalty”.
Lampard tried to keep a lid on it, to talk about progression and spirit and the need to keep working. Underneath, the sense of injustice was obvious.
A night that could echo
Strip away the controversy and Everton still emerge with something important: resilience, goals from their main striker, and a home crowd that feels fully engaged again. “It’s always a pleasure to play at home,” Barry said. You could hear why. The noise barely dipped from first whistle to last.
Coventry leave with nothing tangible, only the knowledge they went toe-to-toe with a side in form and forced them into a scrap. Perform like this often enough, the results usually follow. If the big calls start to fall their way, they will feel even more dangerous.
For Everton, the question now is simple. With Barry chasing Haaland in the scoring charts, Dewsbury-Hall playing like an international-in-waiting and Moyes quietly knitting the pieces together, how far can this momentum really take them?






