Erling Haaland and Man City Stars Could Leave for Free After Guilty Verdict, Legal Expert Says
Manchester City faces a possible departure of some of its top players following the Premier League's ruling against the club in a major financial misconduct case. A prominent legal expert has indicated that stars like Erling Haaland might have the right to leave the Etihad Stadium without any transfer fee.
Guilty Verdict Raises Contract Concerns
The Premier League's investigation concluded with Manchester City being found guilty on 114 out of 115 charges, including the use of fake contracts with commercial partners between 2009 and 2018. This verdict has sparked uncertainty over the future of key players at the club. Although Manchester City is preparing an appeal and denies wrongdoing, the decision has triggered speculation that players could invoke employment law to terminate their contracts early and for free.
Legal Insight: Trust and Confidence in Contracts
On the "Stick to Football" podcast, barrister Paul Gilroy KC explained how players might have grounds to leave. He said every employment contract carries an implied term of trust and confidence between employer and employee. If this trust is broken, the player could claim a breach of contract and choose to end their agreement immediately.
"If you don't trust me, or I don't trust you, or if you call me a liar and a thief one day, I can't work for you the next," Gilroy noted. "A player could say, 'You breached trust and confidence. That lets me rip up my contract and walk away.'"
Rival Clubs Watch Closely
This legal possibility prompted lighthearted comments among football pundits. When asked if clubs like Liverpool could sign Haaland for free, Gilroy responded simply, "Yeah, why not?" Arsenal legend Ian Wright joked that Haaland might fancy a move to North London due to friendships there. While humorous, these remarks underline the potential upheaval in transfer markets if City's players were able to legally cancel their contracts.
Next Steps: City's Appeal and On-Field Focus
Attention now turns to Manchester City's appeal against the ruling, which must be submitted by Friday. The final outcome will influence any sporting penalties and determine how this situation unfolds. Meanwhile, manager Enzo Maresca and his squad must concentrate on their matches despite the off-field distractions. Until the appeal concludes, the threat of contract terminations remains a serious cloud over the club.
- Premier League fixture: Liverpool vs Manchester City
- Date: 11 Oct 2026
- Kick-off time: 18:30






