In Florence, Juventus walked off the pitch shaking their heads and pointing at the big screen, not the scoreboard. A wild 2-2 draw with Fiorentina should have ended with a chance to win it from the spot. Instead, a late handball shout against Joao Mario went unanswered, and the Bianconeri were left with a result that feels far more like a defeat than a point gained.
Chaos, comebacks and a whistle that never blew
The game itself had already swung like a pendulum. Fiorentina struck first through Mateo Pellegrino, seizing the initiative and forcing Juventus to chase. Nick Woltemade dragged the visitors level, only for Alieu Njie to restore the Viola’s lead and ignite the home crowd again.
Juventus refused to fold. Gleison Bremer powered them back to 2-2, a goal that underlined the visitors’ resolve and briefly tilted the night in their favour. At that stage, with the momentum theirs and Fiorentina retreating, it felt as though there was only one team likely to snatch it.
Then came the flashpoint.
In the dying moments, a ball fired into the Fiorentina box struck Joao Mario on the arm. Juventus players appealed instantly, surrounding the referee, arms raised in disbelief. The official waved play on. No whistle, no trip to the monitor. VAR stayed silent.
The chance to turn one point into three vanished in an instant.
VAR under fire
The fallout was immediate. Across Italy, the decision dominated the post-match debate far more than any of the four goals.
Leading sports dailies La Gazzetta dello Sport, Tuttosport and Corriere dello Sport all reached the same conclusion: it should have been a penalty. For them, the images were clear enough. Handball. Spot-kick. Juventus robbed of a decisive moment.
Former referee and DAZN analyst Luca Marelli dissected the incident with the precision of someone who has been in the middle of these storms before. He rejected the idea that a deflection could excuse the contact.
“The point of contact is below the elbow, more on the arm than in the armpit,” Marelli told DAZN, underlining that the crucial area was clearly within the punishable zone. The ball had taken an unexpected path, he acknowledged, glancing off a missed header from Kolo Muani and then a boot before reaching Joao Mario. But for Marelli, the key detail lay elsewhere.
Joao Mario’s arm, he pointed out, was hanging at a stark 90-degree angle, far from his body. Unnatural. Extended. A classic trigger for a handball call in the modern game.
“There is no doubt the Fiorentina player touched the ball with his arm, and he should have been punished,” Marelli added. Labeling the contact “unexpected,” he argued, was just one possible interpretation, not a justification for inaction. In his view, VAR had one clear duty: send the referee to the monitor and let him make the decision from there.
That never happened. And Juventus, already back in the dressing room by the time the replays were being frozen and rewound on studio screens, could only stew.
Two points lost in the race for Serie A ground
Strip away the controversy and the table still bites. Juventus sit seventh, marooned in mid-pack on 18 points from 11 matches. A club built on titles and pressure games now finds itself scrambling just to close the gap on the leading pack.
Their reaction in Florence showed personality. Twice they trailed, twice they answered. That kind of resilience usually earns praise and a platform to build on. Yet the mood around this draw is very different. With the late incident looming over everything, it feels like a missed opportunity, a night when character met a ceiling imposed by a decision – or indecision – in the VAR room.
For Fiorentina, the story is more straightforward. They bent but did not break, survived the late scare, and clung to a point that keeps them 15th on nine points. It is not glamorous, but in a season that already threatens to become a grind, every scrap matters.
Juventus do not think in scraps. They think in streaks, in climbs up the table, in chases of league leaders who are already edging away. To catch them, draws like this must turn into wins. Margins will decide whether this campaign is salvaged or written off, and in Florence, that margin was an arm held just a little too far from a body – and a monitor that stayed dark.






