logo

League One Clubs Demand Stricter Spending Rules Amid Rising Losses

League One’s owners are back at the negotiating table, and this time they want the financial handbrake pulled even tighter.

Barely half a year after clubs voted to rein in spending by cutting allowable squad costs from 60% to 50% of turnover, a significant number now want deeper cuts, stricter limits and far less room for owner-funded gambles.

Two new models are on the table. One would cap the total amount a club can lose over a rolling three‑year period. The other would bring in a so‑called luxury tax: any owner investment above a set threshold would trigger a 50% levy, redistributed to rivals across the division. Those close to the talks say the loss cap is emerging as the preferred route.

This is not a tweak. It is an attempt to redraw the financial map of the third tier.

A division that cannot stop spending

Last summer’s rule change was supposed to mark a reset. Clubs agreed to reduce the proportion of income that can be spent on wages from 60% to 50%, scrapping the old staggered approach to owner investment. Now, only half of any equity injection can go on squad costs; the rest must be channelled into infrastructure.

Managers’ salaries were dragged into the calculation for the first time as well. On paper, that looked like a major tightening.

On the ground, spending has kept climbing.

Losses in League One averaged £7.5m per club last season, up sharply from £5.3m the year before. Wage bills have risen by around 15% again this campaign. One owner, speaking to the Guardian, framed the problem bluntly: the clubs have shown, time and again, that they cannot restrain themselves.

The financial arms race is brutal. A budget that would have secured a top‑six finish five years ago, the same owner said, would now barely keep a club out of the bottom three.

Pressure from above, warning signs below

The push for tougher regulation has been building quietly for months, but the publication of last month’s State of the Game report has turned background concern into urgency.

The Independent Football Regulator’s first major piece of work painted a stark picture: 94% of clubs in the EFL and National League are loss‑making, and 32 of the 96 would not survive a single month without owner funding. The game’s financial model, particularly in the lower leagues, is being held together by benefactors’ chequebooks.

For some, that reliance has become intolerable risk. Reading and Peterborough have been among the most vocal advocates of tighter spending controls, arguing that a more disciplined framework is the only way to protect clubs from the boom‑and‑bust cycle that has scarred the pyramid for decades.

They do not speak for everyone. MK Dons and Wycombe are among those pushing back, wary of rules that might shackle ambition or entrench the status quo. Any new system would need a two‑thirds majority to pass, and at this stage that threshold is far from guaranteed.

Legal storm clouds

All of this is unfolding under the shadow of a legal fight.

The Professional Footballers’ Association has already launched proceedings against the current rules, arguing that clubs failed to honour the terms of their membership of the professional negotiating and consultative committee before forcing through last summer’s changes.

It is not the first collision between the PFA and the leagues over pay controls. An attempt in 2021 by League One and League Two to impose hard salary caps of £2.5m and £1.5m respectively collapsed after the union took the matter to independent arbitration. The caps were withdrawn.

That history hangs over the latest proposals. Any move to squeeze spending further risks another confrontation with the players’ union, even as clubs insist that the alternative is a continued slide into unsustainable losses.

The Championship gap

There is another fear inside League One boardrooms: that in trying to protect themselves, they create an even steeper cliff to the division above.

One senior figure at a League One club warned that stricter rules could leave promoted teams hopelessly underpowered in the Championship. That league has relaxed its own regulations, allowing owners to inject up to £33m over three years as equity, outside the 85% wage‑to‑revenue limit.

For clubs dreaming of promotion, that is a chasm. Clamp down too hard in League One and the jump becomes not just competitive but financial, with newly promoted sides stepping into a division where rivals can call on far greater owner backing.

League Two, for now, sits on the sidelines. Those clubs are not formally part of the current talks, but the expectation within the game is clear: whatever model League One eventually settles on, League Two is likely to follow.

The EFL has declined to comment, but the direction of travel is unmistakable. The third tier is trying to decide what kind of league it wants to be: a stage for owner‑funded gambles, or a tightly policed competition where survival off the pitch matters as much as success on it.

The next vote will show how many are really prepared to change.