Liverpool should have had a penalty. Not in the heat of the moment, not just in the court of public opinion, but according to the Premier League’s own independent Key Match Incidents panel.
In a verdict that will do nothing to cool the debate around officiating, the panel ruled that Jurrien Timber’s shirt pull on Alexander Isak in Arsenal’s 1-0 win at Anfield should have resulted in a spot-kick – and that VAR should have stepped in when referee Andy Madley did not.
Panel says penalty, VAR should intervene
The incident came in the 21st minute on November 1, with Arsenal already 1-0 up thanks to Kai Havertz’s strike, which ultimately decided the game. Bradley Barcola whipped in a cross, Isak moved to attack it seven yards out, and Timber, on the wrong side, grabbed at the striker’s shirt.
Madley waved play on. VAR Stuart Attwell stayed silent.
The KMI panel, which reviews key decisions from every Premier League game, voted 4-1 that Madley should have awarded a penalty. On top of that, a 3-2 majority felt Attwell ought to have sent the referee to the pitchside monitor, judging the non-award as a “clear and obvious error”.
One panellist argued the “short-lived holding” did not clearly affect Isak’s ability to reach the ball. Two others leaned on the high bar for VAR intervention, saying the subjectivity around the impact meant it did not cross that threshold.
The majority disagreed. They saw enough.
‘Do your job’: Pundits furious with VAR
If the panel’s ruling was cool and technical, the pundits’ reaction on the night was anything but.
Jamie Carragher did not bother with diplomacy. “One of the best goalscorers in the league is pulled back seven yards out and it stops him heading the ball – why does he need to make a meal of it? VAR, do your job.”
Ian Wright echoed him. “He shouldn't have to make more of it. We can see it… Unless I'm pulled back, I'm going to head it as much as I can. When he pulled him, it was just about enough as he would need to go down. VAR is wrong in this instance. If they gave that penalty, I wouldn't sit here and say ‘I can't believe they gave that’.”
Gary Neville focused on Isak’s reaction, or lack of it. “It's actually unnatural not to make more of it. When you get pulled and you're just about to score, you ordinarily complain like crazy. It's a very odd reaction from Isak.”
Daniel Sturridge went even further on the body language. “Unfortunately, he has not fallen over. You're supposed to fall over, put your arms in the air and show the referee you're mad about it… to me, his reaction is almost like ‘VAR, do your job’. But they've not done their job. He shouldn't have to make more of it – clearly, he shouldn't. Everyone can see that his arm is stretched, he [Timber] is holding him with a stretched-out arm.”
The thread running through all of it? The sense that a player now has to hit the turf to get what the laws already promise.
‘He should have gone to the floor’: Iraola’s brutal honesty
Andoni Iraola did not hide behind clichés. Liverpool’s head coach was blunt.
“The Isak one is a clear penalty. We can all see that he holds the t-shirt. The ball just goes one centimetre in front of Alex. Alex is going to hit the ball in front of the goal.”
Then came the line that will sting the game’s idealists.
On whether Isak needed to go down, Iraola replied: “The fact that you are even asking me that shows he should have gone to the floor. If he does, they call the penalty 100 per cent.” Asked if he will tell Isak to go down next time, the answer was simple: “Yes, definitely.”
That is the brutal reality modern forwards live in: stay honest, risk getting nothing.
Virgil van Dijk shared the frustration. “I've seen it back and I've seen it given as well on other occasions. Today it wasn't meant to be.
“The VAR doesn't notice it? There are 50 cameras. Even more. Why does he have to complain when there are so many cameras? It is spotted because everyone's seen it. In the end, it wasn't given and we lose the game unfortunately, so well done to Arsenal.”
From Arsenal’s side, Mikel Arteta kept his distance, saying he had not watched the incident back and offering no comment.
Gallagher: ‘Big chance, got lucky’
Former Premier League referee Dermot Gallagher, speaking on Ref Watch, laid out how a decision like this can slip through the cracks.
“It depends which angle you watch it from. The first angle, you see nothing. That is the referee's angle. The second angle, which is what VAR looks at, and it is a lot more damning.
“VAR looks at it in slow motion, which is another thing against him. In normal speed, he grabs and grabs him quickly but let's go. Does he do enough [for a penalty]?
“What is Timber's intention? He is on the wrong side of him. Does he do enough to stop him? He [Isak] will say yes, as he is close to the ball.
“VAR would be accused of re-refereeing if it is a penalty. It is a case of damned if they do and damned if they don't.
“It has to be the case of on-field. The more I watch it, the more I think he [Timber] has taken a big chance and has got lucky.”
Jay Bothroyd, looking at the same pictures, could not believe the officials’ collective blind spot. “Where was the referee? Every angle, I can see it is a penalty.
“He has pulled his shirt. How can none of them [referee and VAR] see that and say it is a penalty? I can't comprehend that. I don't get it.
“That is one of the most obvious penalties [I have seen]. He is running forward! He has stifled his momentum going forward, to stop him heading the ball.
“Every angle I look at, even normal time, I said it could be a penalty. I look at it now, the more I see it, the more I ask myself how they have missed it! How do they lose focus and not get that.”
Mac Allister booking backed by panel
Not every Liverpool complaint found support.
Late in the second half, Alexis Mac Allister went down clutching his face after his forehead made contact with Noni Madueke’s. VAR checked for violent conduct. No red card, just a yellow for Mac Allister.
On that one, the KMI panel were unanimous. They agreed the referee was right not to dismiss Madueke, describing the contact as “negligible” and Mac Allister’s reaction as “clearly exaggerated”.
In an era where any contact near the head sparks chaos, this was one flashpoint the officials handled to the panel’s satisfaction.
Ipswich also denied from the spot
The Anfield controversy was not the only error flagged.
The panel also found that Ipswich Town should have had a penalty in their 2-2 draw with Hull City on October 3. With the game goalless in the 18th minute, Nobel Mendy was judged to have committed a holding offence on Dara O’Shea at a corner.
This time the vote was again 4-1 that referee Tom Kirk should have pointed to the spot, and that VAR Neil Davies should have recommended an on-field review. The majority saw “a clear sustained holding offence”, while one panellist felt the actions of O’Shea and Florentino Luis during the tussle meant a penalty was not justified.
Across the season, the Premier League leans on these numbers to defend its officials. Of 196 key match incidents reviewed so far, the panel says the on-field decision has been correct 86 per cent of the time, rising to 97 per cent once VAR steps in.
But numbers do not quiet the noise when a title race, a European push or a relegation scrap turns on a single shirt tug in the six-yard box – and when the game’s own experts later admit the whistle should have blown.






