logo

Manchester United Manager Odds: 23 Candidates to Succeed Michael Carrick

Michael Carrick initially brought hope when he took over as interim manager in January, improving Manchester United’s performance after Ruben Amorim’s difficult tenure. No Premier League manager collected more points than him during that period, and with Champions League qualification secured, the club appointed him permanently. Yet, the new season has been harsh.

United have managed only one victory in their first six league matches of 2026/27. A home loss to Manchester City, who played most of the match with ten men, was a notable low. Additionally, they squandered a 2-0 halftime lead against Brighton in the Carabao Cup, losing 3-2, marking the first time in 50 years United lost at home after leading by two goals at halftime. Other disappointing moments include blowing a 1-0 lead to Tottenham, again against a ten-man side, conceding a late equalizer, and a 2-0 defeat to Atletico Madrid. Following this last loss, Lisandro Martinez criticized the club’s lack of investment, adding pressure on Carrick. SkyBet has released odds on 23 potential replacements should the situation worsen.

Long Shots with 80/1 Odds

  • Lionel Scaloni – Argentina national team coach
  • Ange Postecoglou – Al-Nassr manager
  • David Moyes – Everton manager

David Moyes, once considered the ideal successor by Sir Alex Ferguson, faces skepticism. Postecoglou and Lionel Scaloni share similar odds, but the job is famously demanding. Ralf Rangnick, who was interim boss in 2021/22 and left frustrated, is rated at 66/1 alongside Roberto Mancini. Diego Simeone, Atletico Madrid’s boss known for a defensive style, stands at 50/1 odds.

Moderate Odds at 50/1

  • Daniel Farke – Leeds United manager
  • Brendan Rodgers – Al Qadsiah manager
  • Sebastian Hoeness – VfB Stuttgart manager

Farke has shown promise with Leeds, winning the Championship and avoiding relegation, but managing a club like United would be a significant step up. Rodgers seeks a return to English football, while Hoeness is also considered a possibility.

Mid-Range Contenders Between 33/1 and 14/1

  • Luis Enrique – PSG manager (33/1)
  • Ole Gunnar Solskjaer – Unattached, former United player and manager (25/1)
  • Mauricio Pochettino – USA national team coach (25/1)
  • Roberto Martinez – Unattached (22/1)
  • Darren Fletcher – Manchester United U18 head coach (20/1)
  • Carlo Ancelotti – Brazil national team coach (20/1)
  • Gareth Southgate – Unattached, former England manager (14/1)

Luis Enrique’s success with PSG makes him an intriguing candidate despite the lower challenge there. Solskjaer and Pochettino are familiar names to United fans, while Martinez’s Premier League experience counts. Fletcher’s role with the youth side suggests a temporary solution. Ancelotti’s recent World Cup exit and Southgate’s free-agent status place them in the mix as well.

Top Picks with Odds from 14/1 to 2/1

  • Unai Emery – Aston Villa manager (14/1)
  • Thomas Tuchel – England manager (14/1)
  • Kieran McKenna – Unattached, former United assistant (10/1)
  • Julian Nagelsmann – Unattached (13/2)
  • Antonio Conte – Napoli manager (5/1)
  • Fabian Hurzeler – Brighton & Hove Albion manager (5/1)
  • Eddie Howe – Unattached (2/1)

Emery has a strong Premier League record despite a rough Arsenal spell. Tuchel’s current job makes a move unlikely before Euro 2028. McKenna, familiar with United’s setup, remains an option. Nagelsmann’s Bundesliga successes and availability make him attractive. Conte is renowned for delivering immediate results. Hurzeler, though young, has impressed at Brighton. The favorite is Howe, recently leaving Newcastle and expected to return quickly to management.

Summary of Odds and Candidates

  • 80/1: Lionel Scaloni, Ange Postecoglou, David Moyes
  • 66/1: Roberto Mancini, Ralf Rangnick
  • 50/1: Diego Simeone, Daniel Farke, Brendan Rodgers, Sebastian Hoeness
  • 33/1: Luis Enrique
  • 25/1: Ole Gunnar Solskjaer, Mauricio Pochettino
  • 22/1: Roberto Martinez
  • 20/1: Darren Fletcher, Carlo Ancelotti
  • 14/1: Gareth Southgate, Unai Emery, Thomas Tuchel
  • 10/1: Kieran McKenna
  • 13/2: Julian Nagelsmann
  • 5/1: Antonio Conte, Fabian Hurzeler
  • 2/1: Eddie Howe

These odds reflect the uncertainty surrounding Manchester United’s next managerial appointment following Carrick’s struggles early in the 2026/27 season.