Manchester United’s summer of confusion has come into sharper focus, and it has claimed its first major casualty.
Michael Carrick is out, sacked with United marooned in 18th place, eight points from their first ten league games. Mauricio Pochettino is expected to walk into the chaos next, but the story unfolding around Old Trafford is less about the man in the dugout and more about the people above him.
A manager sacrificed, a club exposed
Carrick goes with his reputation largely intact in the eyes of many United supporters. He dragged the club back into the Champions League last season and never lost the dressing room or the stands. The sense lingers that he has paid the price for structural failings he could never control.
Those failings are not new. Protests against the Glazer family have rumbled on for years, fuelled by anger at the £600m debt loaded onto the club in a leveraged takeover 21 years ago. Now there is a new target. Sir Jim Ratcliffe, who bought a minority stake in February 2024 and promised a “best in class” operation, finds himself bracketed with the Americans as part of the problem, not the solution.
The promise of elite standards has so far delivered something else entirely.
A £150m midfield – but eighth-choice options
United’s summer recruitment was supposed to mark the beginning of a new era. Instead, it has become a case study in how not to run an elite club.
With Casemiro gone and the hierarchy having given up on Manuel Ugarte ever becoming the answer, a midfield rebuild was unavoidable. On paper, they spent big: Andrey Santos, Carlos Baleba and Youri Tielemans arrived for a combined £150m.
Scratch the surface, though, and the picture changes. Those three, according to detailed reporting from The Athletic, were not the club’s first choices. Not even close.
United had drawn up a long list of midfield targets. Elliot Anderson sat at the very top. Behind him came Mateus Fernandes, Sandro Tonali, Aurelien Tchouameni, Alex Scott, Ederson and Ayyoub Bouaddi. Only after those names did Santos, Baleba and Tielemans enter the conversation.
In other words, United ended up signing players who were seventh or eighth on their own shortlist.
The Anderson pursuit underlines the dysfunction. A separate report on Thursday claimed the England international actually wanted to join United. The move never materialised because Jason Wilcox, the club’s director of football, did not get close to the selling club’s valuation. Manchester City did. They paid £116m and took Anderson instead.
For a club that once made a habit of landing its top targets, the contrast is stark.
Leaders under scrutiny
The scrutiny now falls heavily on the new football structure Ratcliffe has installed. Omar Berrada, the CEO, and Wilcox were billed as key pillars of the “best in class” promise. Their early work has raised more questions than answers.
Few inside or outside Old Trafford would describe this summer as a model of elite planning. Carrick, for one, certainly would not. He wanted “significantly more than was delivered,” particularly a backup striker and a left-back to balance the squad. He got neither.
Even the deals that did happen were muddled. The Athletic reports that United “gave serious consideration” to signing Leon Goretzka on a free instead of Tielemans. Goretzka did end up replacing Tielemans – but at Aston Villa, where he scored against United in what proved to be Carrick’s final game in charge. The symbolism was brutal.
This is not just about bad luck in the market. It is about a process that seems designed to slow decisions to a crawl.
Six signatures for one signing
Agents dealing with United have described a “complicated” system just to get a straight answer. Multiple executives have to be looped in, persuaded, and signed off before any deal moves forward.
The chain runs long: Berrada and Wilcox are involved, as are Christopher Vivell, the director of recruitment, and Matt Hargreaves, the director of negotiations. Above them sit Ratcliffe and the Glazers, whose ratification is required for every transfer.
Six different individuals. One transfer.
In a hyper-competitive market where rivals move quickly and decisively, United are dragging themselves through their own bureaucracy. By the time they reach a conclusion, the player is often gone – as Anderson’s move to City underlined.
Pochettino walks into the storm
Into this environment steps Pochettino, expected to be announced imminently. He will inherit a squad built on compromise, a fanbase that has run out of patience, and an ownership structure that has managed to alienate almost everyone.
Carrick’s dismissal might be the headline, but the deeper story is about a club that cannot decide what it wants to be, or who is truly in charge of making it so. United have spent heavily, talked loudly and promised the world.
Now they face a harsher question: how many more managers will they burn through before the people making the decisions finally prove they belong at Old Trafford?






