logo

What’s Next for Michael Carrick at Manchester United?

After Manchester United's 3-0 loss at home to Bournemouth on Sunday, it seemed like Michael Carrick was close to losing his job. Many expected the club to announce his exit on Monday, but that did not happen.

The latest update from The Athletic’s Laurie Whitwell says Carrick will lead training on Tuesday. Still, his future isn't guaranteed, especially with United facing Chelsea this weekend. The club's leaders are in urgent talks about Carrick's role but haven't decided yet.

Potential Replacements for Carrick

Manchester United have already explored options for a new manager. Eddie Howe is reportedly the favorite, with director of football Jason Wilcox supporting his hiring. Julian Nagelsmann is also seen as a strong candidate; he became available after stepping down as Germany's head coach following their early World Cup exit.

Other names like Fabian Hurzeler and Unai Emery have come up, though their current clubs would demand large compensation fees.

Why Carrick Should Stay

Under Carrick, Manchester United have started the 2026-27 season poorly, with just one win in eight Premier League matches and sitting only one point above the relegation zone. Still, Carrick isn’t the only one responsible for this slump.

The club’s management did not support him in the transfer market, refusing to bring in key players such as a striker or a left-back. On the pitch, the players aren’t performing fully either. Instead of focusing on their own form, they’ve been blaming Carrick and the club’s board in interviews.

Removing Carrick won’t fix Manchester United's deeper problems. The club has faced ongoing challenges since Sir Alex Ferguson retired in 2013, cycling through several top managers without finding lasting success.