The scoreboard at Goodison told one story. The away end told another.
As Newcastle United slipped out of the EFL Cup with a 3-1 defeat to Everton, the loudest roar from nearly 8,000 travelling supporters was not for Dan Burn’s late consolation. It came a few minutes earlier, when Sean Steur finally appeared from the bench in the 81st minute, with his side already 3-0 down and the tie long gone.
It was a cheer laced with sarcasm and frustration. And Matthias Jaissle will have heard every decibel.
Big fee, small role
Newcastle did not sign Steur to make up the numbers. The Dutch midfielder arrived from Ajax in the summer for €23.5 million, a deal that could rise to €27 million with bonuses. That sort of outlay usually buys a key starter, not a late cameo specialist.
He did begin the 2-1 win over Hull City on 19 September, a performance that looked like the start of a proper run in the side. Instead, it has proved the exception. Since that night, Steur has been reduced to brief substitute appearances or left to watch all 90 minutes from the bench.
Jaissle has been clear about his preference for Nico González in midfield. The team sheet keeps reflecting that stance. Steur keeps paying the price.
Everton déjà vu, different stakes
Thursday’s Cup tie underlined the pecking order. In a fourth-round match that offered fringe players a chance to stake a claim, the former Ajax man again found himself among the substitutes. As Everton raced into a 3-0 lead, Jaissle waited until the final 10 minutes to turn to his big-money signing.
By then, the contest was effectively over. Steur stepped onto the pitch to that pointed ovation from the away end, a reaction as much about the manager’s selection as the player himself. Burn’s goal came shortly afterwards, but it barely softened the exit.
Newcastle face Everton again on Monday, this time in the Premier League. On current evidence, Steur is likely to be back in his now-familiar role: watching González start ahead of him.
Fans losing patience as defence crumbles
The discontent is no longer confined to social media debates about line-ups. At the final whistle on Thursday, loud boos poured down from the travelling support. The anger was not only about one Cup defeat or one selection call.
Newcastle have shipped 11 goals in their last four away games. They look fragile, open, and too easy to play through on the road. In that context, leaving a €23.5 million midfielder on the sidelines for long stretches only sharpens the questions.
Is Jaissle right to stand so firmly by González? Could Steur offer more control, more bite, or simply a different rhythm in a midfield that has struggled to protect a leaky back line?
For now, the manager is unmoved, the player is waiting, and the fans are making themselves heard. Monday’s return to Goodison will not just be about points; it will be another test of Jaissle’s resolve over a decision that is starting to define Newcastle’s season.






