logo

Newcastle United: From Glory to Uncertainty Amidst a Tough Season

Thirty years on from Keegan’s five-goal thunderbolt against Manchester United, Newcastle United chose to remember the night St James’ Park shook. The timing felt deliberate. A reminder of what this club once was, on a week when the present feels muddled and strangely flat.

The clip went up on X for 2.8 million followers to savour: Ginola, Beardsley, Ferdinand, the sheer swagger of it all. A team that knew exactly what it was.

Matthias Jaissle’s Newcastle do not.

From swagger to uncertainty

Newcastle travel to Selhurst Park on Sunday to face a struggling Crystal Palace side with a simple brief: stop the slide. Three defeats in four, eight points from seven games, and a chorus of boos ringing around St James’ Park after last weekend’s limp loss to Aston Villa have sharpened the mood on Tyneside.

Leeds United 4-1 Newcastle on 14 September. Coventry City 4-1 Newcastle on 12 October. Two heavy away beatings that stripped away any illusion this was just a slow start. The numbers are starting to stack up against Jaissle.

“The pressure will seriously be on if they don't get a result at Palace,” says Charlotte Robson from the True Faith Newcastle United podcast.

Supporters are not yet in open revolt, but they are restless. They talk about a team without an identity, a side that has lost its way at both ends of the pitch.

They also talk about Alexander Isak.

Fourteen months after his British record £125m move to Liverpool, Newcastle still have not found anything close to a like-for-like answer. The same could be said for Callum Wilson, who left in the same summer. Yoane Wissa was brought in to fill that void, Nick Woltemade to step into Isak’s shoes. One has battled inconsistency after injury, the other is on loan at Juventus less than a year after arriving in a club-record deal worth up to £69m.

For a club that once built its modern revival on smart, targeted recruitment, the recent picture looks far less coherent.

A squad stripped of stars

Alan Shearer saw this coming.

“Speaking purely as a fan, I think we have to get ready for a tough season and some very challenging times ahead,” he warned in July, days after Eddie Howe walked away having delivered the club’s first major domestic trophy since 1955.

By then, the dismantling had already begun. Anthony Gordon sold to Barcelona in a deal worth more than £69m. Sandro Tonali to Tottenham for up to £100m. A week later, Bruno Guimaraes gone to Arsenal for £75m. Then Kieran Trippier, the 36-year-old England defender who had become one of the dressing room’s loudest leaders, also departed.

“You cannot keep on selling your best players and then hope to be in contention at the top of the table,” Shearer said.

Seven games into the new campaign, Newcastle sit on eight points, with only two league wins – away at Tottenham and at home to newly promoted Hull City. So far, the club’s greatest goalscorer is being proved right.

Rory Smith, football correspondent of the Observer, joined the dots on BBC Radio 5 Live’s The Monday Night Club. “If you had said at the end of last season Newcastle would lose Gordon, Guimaraes, Tonali and Howe, you would probably get this [eight points from seven games],” he argued.

The recruitment strategy has been bold, but it has also been unforgiving on the manager.

Newcastle spent about £250m in the summer, largely on players aged 21 or under. Bazoumana Toure and Aladji Bamba are yet to start a Premier League game despite being available. Sean Steur, the 18-year-old who caught the eye when he started against Hull in September, has not played a single minute since.

“The profile of the players Newcastle signed in the summer, and it may well bear fruit in time... they went very young and relatively inexperienced,” Smith said. “They didn't go out and sign a load of established Premier League players.”

A big reputation, a hard landing

Newcastle paid Al-Ahli £9.5m in compensation to prise Jaissle away after he delivered back-to-back Asian Champions League titles. His work at Red Bull Salzburg had already marked him out as one of Europe’s most intriguing young coaches. On paper, it was a coup.

On grass, in the Premier League, it has been a harsh introduction.

Seventy-nine days into his reign, Jaissle is still wrestling with the legacy of Howe’s five-year tenure while trying to impose a very different style. The result is a side caught between ideas, neither as aggressive nor as secure as the manager promised.

Chris Sutton, watching the Villa defeat for BBC Radio 5 Live, did not sugar-coat it. Newcastle, he said, look “chaotic” under Jaissle. “There is not enough in the final third in terms of creativity and they have a vulnerability at the back,” he added.

The numbers back him up. Newcastle have gone 16 home games in all competitions without a clean sheet, the longest such run in the club’s history. They are conceding an average of two goals per Premier League match; only Crystal Palace (17) and Ipswich (15) have let in more than their 14.

At the other end, the Villa game offered a brutal snapshot of the current malaise. One shot on target in 90 minutes at St James’ Park, their lowest total in a home league game since August 2024. That lone effort came from centre-back Sven Botman. By the end, Jaissle had pushed another defender, Dan Burn, up front in search of something, anything.

“Newcastle fans have every right to be a little bit concerned,” Sutton said. “They didn't look like scoring against Villa and that is what really concerns Newcastle fans.”

Calm at the top, questions in the stands

Inside the club, the message is calm. CEO David Hopkinson and sporting director Ross Wilson are not reaching for the panic button. Jaissle, 38 and unproven in this league, is expected to be given time to make sense of an expensively rebuilt, dramatically younger squad.

Robson agrees that patience is needed after a summer of upheaval. But patience has limits, especially in a season that has already asked so many questions of the new regime.

“There are more questions being asked now,” she says. “At the start of the season it was made clear in interviews we wanted to be an aggressive attacking team. We are not there yet, we're still working it out.”

That is the nub of it. The vision has been loudly stated. The reality has been timid.

Newcastle’s next four games will test the club’s resolve and the supporters’ tolerance. Palace away on Sunday. Everton twice in a week – first at Goodison Park in the Carabao Cup last-16 next Thursday, then at St James’ Park in the league on 2 November – before a trip to Fulham five days later.

Jaissle will not want to hit the international break without a win in six league and cup matches. He knows how quickly atmospheres can turn in English football, how fast a project can be rebranded as a problem.

The club marked the 30-year anniversary of a famous 5-0 as a nod to what Newcastle once were. The question now is sharper, more urgent.

What exactly are they becoming?