Who Might Step In After Michael Carrick at Manchester United?
Michael Carrick faces growing pressure as Manchester United's poor run continues. The club has not won in eight matches across all competitions, and recent defeats have deepened concerns. A heavy 4-1 loss to Como in the Champions League was followed by a 3-0 home defeat to Bournemouth, with fans leaving Old Trafford early on Sunday.
Though the issues extend beyond just the manager, criticism of Carrick’s tactics from captain Bruno Fernandes and his subsequent benching have added fuel to speculation about Carrick’s future. With the club already having parted ways with Erik ten Hag and Ruben Amorim since Ineos took over football operations, talks about potential replacements are underway.
Before the Bournemouth game, Carrick delivered a passionate pre-match speech stressing sacrifice, humility, and hard work as core values representing Manchester United. Still, the search for someone to turn around the campaign is intensifying.
Possible Successors for Carrick
Eddie Howe
After stepping down from Newcastle United this summer, Eddie Howe is available and reportedly favored by bookmakers. Known for rescuing Newcastle from relegation danger and guiding them to their best Premier League finish in 20 years, he also led them to a Carabao Cup win in 2025. His high-energy style, combined with experience taking Newcastle into the Champions League twice, makes him an appealing choice for United.
Fabian Hurzeler
Fabian Hurzeler, Brighton’s 33-year-old coach, has impressed this season by turning the Seagulls into serious contenders. Brighton's 3-0 triumph over Arsenal and their Carabao Cup victory against United highlight his coaching skills. Despite admiration at Old Trafford, Brighton would demand a significant fee, which might be tough for United. Hurzeler himself remains focused on Brighton, emphasizing the importance of building long-term connections within the club.
Julian Nagelsmann
Former Bayern Munich and RB Leipzig coach Julian Nagelsmann has been linked with United before. Though Germany’s early World Cup exit was a setback for him, the 39-year-old remains a candidate. He has connections with United's recruitment director and could be interested in the role.
Unai Emery
At Aston Villa, Unai Emery has secured Champions League qualification and ended a trophy drought by winning the Europa League. Villa’s rebuild under Emery is ongoing, and they are eager to keep him. Emery has full control at Villa Park, which may not be the case at United, plus the financial cost could be a barrier.
Antonio Conte
Antonio Conte is known for demanding intensity and urgency, qualities some feel United lack this season. His record includes Serie A titles with Juventus, Inter Milan, Napoli, and a Premier League title with Chelsea. Conte revived Tottenham five years ago, bringing them back to the Champions League. Yet, his outspoken nature and previous clashes with club leadership make him a risky appointment. Conte has publicly denied any advanced talks with clubs, saying he is carefully considering when to return to management.
Cesc Fabregas
The former Arsenal, Barcelona, and Chelsea midfielder Cesc Fabregas has gained praise as a young coach. His Como team recently shocked United in the Champions League. Fabregas owns a stake in Como and seems committed to their project. Returning to a major club like Barcelona or even United may be a future possibility, but for now, he appears focused on his current job.
Another Interim Manager?
Manchester United has relied on interim managers before. Darren Fletcher, currently Under-18s coach, stepped in briefly after Amorim’s dismissal earlier this year. Ruud van Nistelrooy and Ole Gunnar Solskjaer also served as temporary bosses in recent years. Many former players remain connected to the club and could take charge in difficult times. Fletcher might be the next to get the call if United opts for another internal solution.
- Eddie Howe: Available, led Newcastle to Carabao Cup in 2025, highly rated in England.
- Fabian Hurzeler: Brighton manager, praised for tactical skill, expensive option.
- Julian Nagelsmann: Former Bayern and Leipzig coach, previously linked with United.
- Unai Emery: Aston Villa boss, Champions League qualification, contract until 2029.
- Antonio Conte: Experienced winner, outspoken, distanced himself from rumors.
- Cesc Fabregas: Young coach at Como, rising reputation, committed to current project.
- Darren Fletcher: Under-18s manager, past interim caretaker at United.






