logo

NWSL Players Win Major Settlement Over Controversial HIP Rule

The NWSL’s most controversial roster rule has been ripped up and rewritten – and this time, the players won.

After months of tension, the NWSL and the NWSL Players Association have agreed to a settlement that strips away the restrictive criteria around the High Impact Player (HIP) designation, clearing the way for any player in the league to earn its top salaries.

A rule built for stars – but on the league’s terms

The HIP rule arrived late last year with a clear purpose: stop the talent drain to Europe. The league handed clubs an extra $1m to spend above the salary cap to sign or retain star players, on top of the $3.7m cap already set for the 2026 season.

But that money came with strings. To qualify as a High Impact Player, an athlete had to tick at least one of eight boxes. US national team minutes. Ballon d’Or recognition. NWSL Best XI honors. Placement on media lists such as the Guardian’s Top 100. Even rankings based on “marketability.”

On paper, it was a mechanism to reward the elite. In practice, it carved up the locker room.

Roughly 100 players fit the criteria, including headline names like Trinity Rodman and Sophia Smith. Yet the list would have shut out others with undeniable pedigree and impact, such as two-time NWSL MVP Sam Kerr and US forward Catarina Macario. The message was hard to ignore: the league, not the clubs, would define who counted as a star.

The NWSLPA pushed back hard. The union filed a grievance, arguing that the classification system violated federal labor law and the existing collective bargaining agreement. What followed was a standoff over who controls value in a league trying to grow at breakneck speed.

Settlement reshapes the power balance

On Friday, that standoff ended with a sweeping settlement. The old criteria are gone.

From 1 January 2027, clubs will be free to designate any player as a High Impact Player, as long as that player’s salary is at least 12% of the base salary cap. The league retains the right to cap how many HIP slots each club can use, but the gatekeeping over who qualifies has been dismantled.

Six grievances were resolved in total. One of the most closely watched involved the Washington Spirit’s attempt to sign Rodman to a blockbuster deal before the HIP rule even existed.

Back in November, the Spirit tried to re-sign Rodman on a contract that would have averaged more than $1m per year. NWSL commissioner Jessica Berman blocked it, citing its backloaded structure as a violation of league rules. The NWSLPA responded with a grievance on Rodman’s behalf, branding the refusal a “flagrant violation” of free agency rights.

Weeks later, the league rolled out the HIP rule. The timing was impossible to ignore, and the mechanism quickly picked up an unofficial nickname: the “Rodman Rule.”

Rodman eventually re-signed with Washington in January on a record deal worth more than $2m annually, but the grievance over the blocked contract never went away. It sat as a live dispute even as the new contract became a symbol of the league’s financial ambitions.

Now that grievance has been settled, folded into a broader agreement that reshapes how the NWSL polices its own salary structure.

Transparency, at last

The league still holds the authority to reject contracts it believes are designed to dodge the cap. That power hasn’t disappeared. What has changed is the accountability around it.

Under the new terms, if the NWSL vetoes a deal on salary-cap grounds, it must notify the union and provide an explanation within 72 hours. No more silent blocks. No more black box decision-making.

The league will also be required to provide clubs with regular updates on salary cap figures and revenue across the year. For players and teams trying to plan long-term in a league still defining its financial ceiling, that kind of transparency is not a luxury. It is structural.

Even without the published list of HIP players, the impact of the mechanism has already been visible. Several stars who would have qualified under the original criteria have signed or re-signed on major deals, including Denver’s Lindsey Horan, Orlando’s Barbra Banda and Gotham’s Rose Lavelle. Their contracts now sit inside a system that gives clubs more freedom to decide who is worth stretching for.

Boots, brands and a quiet revolt

The settlement also tackled an issue that might sound minor until you speak to players: boots.

This season, the league fined and warned players for wearing cleats from brands that were not official NWSL sponsors. On game days, footwear became a battleground between league commercial deals and individual endorsement contracts.

That fight is now largely over. The NWSL has agreed to honor most pre-existing endorsement deals and to withdraw previous fines. For players, it’s not just about comfort or superstition. It’s about autonomy over their own image and income in a league where every extra dollar can matter.

A maturing league, and a louder union

Both sides framed the settlement as a sign of a growing, more sophisticated competition.

NWSLPA director Meghann Burke called the agreement evidence of the union’s strength and its commitment to enforcing the CBA. On the league side, executive vice-president Bill Ordower cast the disputes as part of a “mature” labor relationship in a fast-evolving environment, stressing that the deal protects “integrity and competitive balance.”

Strip away the statements and one reality stands out: the players just won a major argument about who gets to define value in the NWSL.

The HIP rule was born out of fear – fear of losing stars to Europe’s free-spending clubs. The revised version looks more like a tool for ambition, one that lets teams decide which players they cannot afford to lose.

From 2027, any player can be that kind of player, if a club is willing to pay the price.

In a league racing to keep pace with its own potential, that shift might prove more important than any single contract.