The Premier League’s own review panel has delivered a damning verdict on the officials at Anfield, ruling that Liverpool should have been awarded a penalty against Arsenal after Alexander Isak was pulled back by Jurrien Timber.
The incident came in the 21st minute on 1 November, with Arsenal already 1-0 up through Kai Havertz in a match they would go on to win by that single goal. Bradley Barcola whipped in a cross, Isak attacked it, and Timber reached for his shirt. The Liverpool forward stayed upright, stretching for the ball, but could not quite get his head to it.
On the day, referee Andy Madley waved play on. VAR Stuart Attwell checked the incident and cleared it. No on-field review. No penalty. No change to the scoreline.
Now, the Premier League’s Key Match Incidents Panel has said both got it wrong.
Panel says ‘clear and obvious’ – but not on the day
The KMI Panel, made up of former players, coaches and referees, voted 4-1 that a penalty should have been awarded on the field for Timber’s foul on Isak.
Crucially, they also judged – by a 3-2 majority – that VAR should have intervened and sent Madley to the pitchside monitor, branding the non-intervention a “clear and obvious error” by the video officials.
Two panellists resisted that conclusion, pointing to what they called the “subjectivity in assessing impact” of the shirt pull as a reason to leave the original decision alone. The majority, though, felt the foul was sufficiently clear to demand action from VAR.
There was no support, however, for the idea that Timber should have been sent off. The panel unanimously agreed that his challenge did not deny an obvious goalscoring opportunity and so did not meet the threshold for a red card.
Isak’s decision to stay on his feet loomed large over the fallout. He did not exaggerate the contact, did not collapse under the tug, and in the moment that restraint cost him – and Liverpool – a spot-kick.
‘The answer is you have to dive’
Liverpool manager Andoni Iraola did not hide his frustration when he spoke to BBC Match of the Day after the game.
“There is a clear grab of the shirt,” he said. “Alex was just in front of him. He was going to head in front of the goal, but couldn't because he grabbed the shirt.
“If he goes to the floor, they call the penalty, 100%. It should be like this, but it is what it is.
“Next time, the managers should tell Alex to go to the floor, otherwise they won't call it.
“The answer is you have to dive. If you don't dive they won't call it.”
Those words land even heavier in the light of the panel’s ruling. The official review effectively backs Iraola’s central complaint: that a clear foul inside the box went unpunished despite VAR having multiple angles and time to assess it.
Arsenal, who were under pressure at that stage, escaped without sanction and protected Havertz’s early strike all the way to full-time. One decision, one goal, three points.
Second VAR mistake in as many days
The KMI Panel’s criticism did not stop at Anfield. It also found fault with VAR in another game played just 24 hours earlier.
On 31 October, Ipswich were denied a penalty against Hull City when Nobel Mendy held back Dara O’Shea at a corner. Referee Peter Bankes missed the infringement, and VAR Neil Davies chose not to intervene.
The panel ruled that Ipswich should have been awarded a spot-kick for Mendy’s holding. At the time, the match was goalless. Ipswich took the lead shortly afterwards, but Hull fought back and the game finished 2-2.
Two games. Two penalties not given. Two VAR teams that, in the eyes of the league’s own experts, failed to correct clear errors.
In an era where every grab, pull and nudge inside the box is replayed in forensic detail, the question now is unavoidable: how many more of these high-stakes calls will it take before trust in the system finally snaps?






