logo

Scotland's Struggles Continue Despite Win Over North Macedonia

Sebastien Pocognoli’s honeymoon as Scotland manager didn’t just end with Slovenia in October. It now feels like the marriage is being held together by stubbornness and shared mortgage rather than love.

Friday night at Hampden brought a win, yes. A necessary, vital win over North Macedonia. But nobody inside the stadium could pretend they enjoyed much of what they watched.

This was Scotland grinding against themselves again. The effort was there, as it almost always is. The running, the tackles, the snarling at lost causes. But when the ball needed to be caressed rather than chased, when moves needed brains rather than brawn, the gaps were glaring. Technique, fluency, conviction in possession – all came and went in fits and starts.

Against a side with no points, no goals and 10 conceded in their first four group games, three points were non-negotiable. A statement victory would have been a bonus. A draw would have been a scandal.

For a worrying spell before the half-hour, the scandal looked very real.

Gilmour’s nightmare, Hampden’s gasp

The first half had brought half-chances, nothing more. Scotland huffed, North Macedonia sat in, and the game plodded along with a tension that felt out of place given the opposition’s record.

Early in the second half, the mood flipped three times in a matter of minutes.

Billy Gilmour, usually the calmest man on the pitch, produced a miss that will live with him for a long time. From point-blank range, with the goal gaping, he ballooned the ball over the bar. It was the kind of sitter that instantly joins the national hall of infamy, bracketed forever with Chris Iwelumo’s horror show against Norway in 2008.

Iwelumo has carried that moment for 16 years. He won’t be alone in that purgatory now. Gilmour, a Napoli midfielder of real class, has years ahead of him to change the story, but this one will be replayed whenever Scotland’s great misses are discussed. The only mercy for him: it didn’t cost any points.

Hampden groaned as one. Then, almost on cue, John McGinn intervened.

The midfielder struck the first of his two goals, and with it came a wave of relief around the old place. The logic was simple: score once against this North Macedonia side and the job is essentially done. Recent history says they barely lay a glove on anyone.

They had failed to register a shot on target against Switzerland in their opener. Managed one against Slovenia. None at all against Scotland in Skopje. Another blank in their second meeting with the Swiss. Their attack had become a rumour.

They offered nothing of note in the first half here either. So when they did score, the shock was almost physical.

A near-post header from Elmin Rastoder, stealing in front of a sleeping Scott McTominay, turned the night on its head. Hampden froze as Rastoder sprinted away, looking as stunned in celebration as Gilmour had looked in disbelief a few minutes earlier.

For North Macedonia, it was a first goal in five Nations League games and a first in nine matches overall. Their last strike had come a year ago, in a 7-1 defeat by Wales. A drought ended, and Scotland suddenly staring at a catastrophe.

McGinn’s rescue act and a hollow triumph

From that moment, the match became a test of nerve rather than quality.

Scotland did what they so often do under pressure: they found a way. Ben Gannon-Doak, deployed at wing-back, drove into the box and won a penalty. McGinn stepped up and hammered it straight down the middle.

Ugly, emphatic, priceless.

Those two goals lifted McGinn beyond Hughie Gallacher in Scotland’s all-time scoring charts. He now sits only six behind Kenny Dalglish and Denis Law, a staggering thought when you consider the company. His contribution to this national team has been immense, and this was another night when he dragged them through a mess of their own making.

There was another milestone in Andy Robertson’s 102nd cap, a mark of extraordinary consistency and endurance. Yet you had to dig deep to find many other positives.

Scotland, back to a three-at-the-back system, looked muddled. The shape never convinced. The patterns of play rarely appeared. Pocognoli’s decision to use Gannon-Doak as a wing-back summed it up: the youngster flitted between winger, full-back and something in between, a square peg in a tactical experiment that never really settled.

Most of the chances Scotland created came from perseverance, not design. Balls won high up the pitch, second phases, individual bursts. This wasn’t a system dismantling a weaker opponent; it was a team straining every sinew to overcome its own confusion.

They didn’t so much impose themselves on North Macedonia as outwork their own doubts.

A nervous glance towards Switzerland – and Slovenia

The table offers a sliver of comfort. The win leaves Scotland a single point behind Slovenia with one game left. Switzerland have already wrapped up top spot. Second place is all that’s left to chase.

On paper, Slovenia hold all the cards. They travel to North Macedonia on Monday in what looks, on form, like a straightforward assignment. Scotland, meanwhile, go to St Gallen to face a Swiss side with nothing at stake and every reason to rotate.

A Swiss second-string might sound like an opportunity, but it could all be academic if Slovenia do their job. The likelihood is Scotland finish third. If that happens, next month’s Euro draw in Belfast becomes an exercise in hope rather than expectation.

Pot three looms. It is not where they wanted to be.

Pocognoli, McGinn and Robertson spoke afterwards. None of them sounded remotely carried away. Grateful for the win, yes. Anything more would have felt dishonest. When Rastoder’s header went in and the whole night teetered on the brink, they would have grabbed at any kind of 2-1. That’s exactly what they got.

What remains is a long list of questions. About systems. About roles. About players being wedged into positions that blunt their strengths. About how a team with this much experience can still look so unsure of itself.

The points are on the board. The performance leaves a warning. Heavy weather against North Macedonia at home; the threat of a real storm still brewing over Switzerland.