Marc-André ter Stegen has waited years for this. A clear run at Germany’s No 1 shirt, the full backing of his national coach, and form in Amsterdam that has finally forced the issue.
And the moment he gets it, the knives come out.
Jürgen Klopp confirmed on Friday that the Barcelona goalkeeper, currently on loan at Ajax, will start both UEFA Nations League games against Serbia and the Netherlands. It is a bold, definitive call: Ter Stegen as first choice, at least for this window, ahead of his rivals.
Klopp did not hesitate to justify it. Ter Stegen’s season in Amsterdam has been outstanding, and the coach spelled that out: “Marc is having a great season in Amsterdam, and fortunately Ortega and Nübel are also having very good seasons. We will go into these two matches with Marc as our first-choice goalkeeper.”
The message was clear. Form matters. Ter Stegen has it.
Hamann lights the fuse
Not everyone sees it that way. Dietmar Hamann, never shy of a strong opinion, tore into the decision and the man at the centre of it.
Speaking to Mundo Deportivo, the former Germany international dismissed Ter Stegen’s elevation in brutal terms. “I don't think he deserves it. He hasn't performed well with the national team,” Hamann said, cutting straight through any sentiment about potential or club form.
He went further. “He is the first-choice goalkeeper because we no longer have Manuel Neuer or Oliver Kahn. I don't think he deserves it.”
It was a direct hit at Ter Stegen’s international record and, by extension, at the depth of Germany’s current goalkeeping pool. For Hamann, the shirt should be earned in a Germany jersey, not on the back of club performances alone.
For Ter Stegen, trying to finally establish himself as Germany’s undisputed No 1, the timing could hardly be more awkward. He has Klopp’s trust, the Nations League stage, and now a very public challenge to his legitimacy.
Kahn steps in on the other side
When a debate about German goalkeepers starts invoking the names Neuer and Kahn, it rarely stays quiet for long. This time, one of those legends stepped into the ring.
Oliver Kahn, the standard-bearer for an entire generation of German keepers, took the opposite view to Hamann and backed Klopp’s call.
“At the moment, Ter Stegen looks to be in good shape. He deserved his call-up. Now he has to prove it through his level of performance,” Kahn said.
No nostalgia, no romanticising the past. Kahn’s stance was simple: current form has earned Ter Stegen his shot; now the judgement moves to the pitch.
It was exactly the kind of endorsement that carries weight in Germany. When Kahn says a goalkeeper has “deserved” his place, people listen.
A nation split over its No 1
So Germany finds itself in a familiar position: arguing about goalkeepers.
On one side, Hamann, insisting Ter Stegen has not done enough in a Germany shirt and owes his status to the absence of Neuer and a bygone Kahn. On the other, Kahn himself, insisting the Barcelona man’s form with Ajax justifies Klopp’s decision and that the real verdict will come in these Nations League fixtures.
Ter Stegen stands between those opinions now as much as he will stand between the posts against Serbia and the Netherlands. The gloves are his. The trust is his.
The question is whether, under this kind of scrutiny, he can finally turn that opportunity into ownership of Germany’s most argued-over position.






