logo

Who Could Replace Mauricio Pochettino as USMNT Coach if He Joins Manchester United?

After signing a long-term deal that would keep him with the United States men's national team through the 2030 World Cup, Mauricio Pochettino's future now seems uncertain. Reports from the UK suggest he is a prime candidate to take over at Manchester United, which would require the club to pay roughly $10 million in compensation to U.S. Soccer, including additional fees for his coaching staff.

With this looming change, the question arises: who might step in to lead the USMNT next?

Pep Guardiola

This is the biggest name on the list but also the most unlikely. Currently on a break after leaving Manchester City following a decade there, Guardiola would need convincing to return early. Known for his affinity for the U.S.—he lived in New York during his sabbatical in 2012/13—and his desire to manage an international team before retiring, he could be a compelling choice. Managing Spain appears off the table due to his Catalan political views, while England is tied to Thomas Tuchel through Euro 2028. Despite turning down Italy last year, there might be a window for U.S. Soccer to present a long-term vision to him.

Roberto Martinez

Martinez offers a more realistic option. The Spanish coach has extensive experience at the international level, having led Belgium and Portugal over the past decade. He was even mentioned as a possible replacement for Pochettino before the World Cup. His tenure includes guiding Belgium to the 2018 World Cup semifinals, though some argue he failed to fully capitalize on the talent at his disposal.

Steve Cherundolo

If Pochettino's departure happens swiftly, U.S. Under-23 coach Cherundolo might take over temporarily, especially for upcoming matches against Haiti. While promoting from within might seem like a safe choice, it has paid off elsewhere—Spain’s Luis de la Fuente is a good example. Cherundolo, 47, only started his current role in July but has shown promise, notably as an assistant when LAFC won both the Supporters' Shield and MLS Cup in 2022. Taking the permanent role would require adjustments to U.S. plans for the 2028 Olympics, but he could bring continuity.

Mikey Varas

Varas also represents a homegrown solution. He coached the U.S. Under-20 team from 2021 to 2023, winning the 2022 CONCACAF U-20 Championship and reaching the quarterfinals of the 2023 FIFA U-20 World Cup. Varas briefly served as interim coach for the senior side before Pochettino’s arrival. Now leading San Diego FC, he guided them to top the Western Conference in their first MLS season in 2025, although they missed the playoffs recently. At 43, he offers youthful energy and familiarity with American soccer development.

B.J. Callaghan

Callaghan led the USMNT as interim coach in 2023, securing the CONCACAF Nations League title before Gregg Berhalter returned. His strongest case now comes from his impressive 2025 season at Nashville SC, where he set franchise records with 22 wins and a 15-game unbeaten streak, along with winning the U.S. Open Cup. Nashville dominated the 2026 regular season with 77 points, 23 wins, and just three losses, making them favorites for the MLS Cup under his leadership.

Rudi Garcia

Garcia, who coached Belgium to a 4-1 victory over the USMNT in the 2026 World Cup before losing to Spain, represents another intriguing possibility. Despite a history of setbacks in his club career, his recent international stint showed promise. Having parted ways with Belgium post-World Cup, he might be interested in continuing on the international stage.

Wilfried Nancy

Another French coach, Nancy, enjoyed success with the Columbus Crew, winning the MLS Cup in 2023 and the Leagues Cup in 2024, earning MLS Coach of the Year honors. Currently available, his brief, difficult spell at Scottish club Celtic last season raises questions about his suitability for an international role, where time to instill complex tactical ideas is limited.