logo

Scott McTominay Transfer Outlook: Premier League Return or Jose Mourinho Reunion at Real Madrid?

Scott McTominay has yet to agree on a new contract with Napoli, stirring plenty of speculation about his next move. Former Scotland international Pat Nevin shared his thoughts with GOAL on what might lie ahead for the midfielder, including a possible reunion with Jose Mourinho at Real Madrid or a return to the Premier League.

From Manchester United to Napoli for £26 Million

McTominay left Manchester United in the summer of 2024, ending a long association with the club. Despite struggles to cement a defined role at Old Trafford—often used as a holding midfielder—the £26 million ($35 million) transfer to Napoli offered him a fresh start.

Many have questioned why United decided to sell a home-grown player known for his dedication, especially given the team’s ongoing consistency issues. Critics also suggest that the club underestimated his ability as a box-to-box midfielder.

Success in Serie A and Rising Profile

At Napoli, McTominay flourished with more freedom to attack. His first season brought a Serie A title and MVP honors. By 2025, he earned votes placing him 18th in the Ballon d’Or rankings.

He improved his goal tally from 13 to 14 in a single season and won over passionate fans alongside his partner, Cam Reading. Though he faced some health challenges recently, McTominay is back in form for the 2026-27 campaign after participating in the World Cup with Scotland. His current contract at Stadio Diego Armando Maradona runs for another 18 months.

Transfer Speculation and Interest from La Liga Giants

With no contract renewal in sight, Napoli must decide whether to sell or risk losing him later. Rumors have linked McTominay to Barcelona previously, but now Real Madrid are reportedly monitoring the situation closely. The connection with Jose Mourinho—who gave him his big break at Manchester United—adds intrigue to the possibility of a reunion.

There’s also talk of McTominay returning to English football, making his next destination a hot topic ahead of the 2027 transfer window.

Pat Nevin’s Take on McTominay’s Next Step

“Such a brilliant question. It’s a tough one because there’s a lot of teams that would have him. I still, to this day, have no idea why Manchester United let him go, which is beyond me. I don’t think they knew his potential and his capabilities that Scotland actually allowed to burst free. I wouldn’t be shocked if he stayed at Napoli, but just about all the Italian teams would be interested in him because they love him, what he’s done there. Can he make the bigger jump a little bit higher? Do you know what? I guess just about anyone would take him. And the reason being, he’s a 10, he’s a six, he’s an eight, he’s a centre-back. I mean, you get four players. And they’re all good. So where do I see him playing? Here’s a weird one - anywhere he likes!”

Where Will McTominay Land Next?

McTominay remains tight-lipped about his future, focusing on his recovery from a minor operation to treat irregular heart rhythms. At 29, he faces a crucial choice: either seek a new challenge abroad, possibly in Spain, settle into a longer stint at Napoli, or circle back to English football.

With perhaps only one major move left in his career, where McTominay ends up will be closely watched by fans and clubs alike.