Nasser Hussain did not bother dressing it up. “I think it’s a complete mess.”
Six years on from Cape Town, Australia’s Sandpapergate scandal is back on the front pages, dragged there by Usman Khawaja’s new book and the uncomfortable questions it poses about what really happened in that Newlands dressing room.
Khawaja’s claims reopen old wounds
Khawaja, part of that infamous 2018 Test, has blown apart the long‑held notion that only three men were in on the plot. His account says the entire team knew about the ball‑tampering scheme, not just Cameron Bancroft, captain Steve Smith and David Warner, the man widely painted as the architect.
He also reveals he was never questioned by Cricket Australia, despite sitting next to Bancroft in the dressing room, and that he urged the side to front up collectively before being talked down by Smith.
For Hussain, speaking on the Sky Sports Cricket Podcast, the whole saga remains staggering.
People have always pushed the line with the ball, he pointed out – mints, sweets, throwing it into the ground, a bit of dirt or Vaseline. Cricket’s dark arts are as old as swing bowling itself. But sandpaper?
“How a side thought it was okay to take sandpaper out,” Hussain said, “how no one before that in a meeting went, ‘I don’t think this is okay, I don’t think we’re doing the right thing’, how they thought they were going to get away with it with all the cameras around, I don’t know.”
The act was bad enough. The cover-up, in his eyes, was worse.
Cricket Australia did not speak to every player. Did not speak to Khawaja, who was right there beside Bancroft. Did not, Hussain feels, live up to the vaunted ideals of the baggy green.
“The team, the baggy green, the mateship and all that stuff – that was what playing Australia was like,” he said. For that same culture to then insist it was “just those three” never rang true to him. “It just feels like a right mess.”
Atherton: CA chose ‘worst of both worlds’
Michael Atherton, on the ground in Australia ahead of England’s white-ball tour, sees the same story from a slightly different angle but with the same conclusion: Cricket Australia mishandled it and was always going to pay for that.
He expects a “circus” when Mitchell Marsh fronts the media this week. Marsh, now white-ball captain, is the only player from that Newlands XI named in the current squad to face England in the ODIs, which begin in Perth on Friday at 3.30am UK time.
Usual ODI captain Pat Cummins has been rested, as have Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Starc. All three played in Cape Town and, along with Nathan Lyon, issued a joint statement in 2021 denying prior knowledge of the sandpaper plan.
Smith and Warner served year-long bans. Bancroft got nine months. The punishments were seismic.
To Atherton, they were also flawed.
“It was almost like the sandpaper was the straw that broke the camel’s back,” he said. This was not an isolated moment of madness. It came, as Khawaja also details, at the end of a period when Australia had become “slightly out of control, a bit unlikable and with a kind of win‑at‑all‑costs mentality.”
Cricket Australia, he argues, then chose the worst possible path.
“They handed down unbelievably heavy sanctions – I thought hard-to-justify sanctions – and left three players to take the rap,” Atherton said. The governing body came down hard, but not wide. That decision left obvious questions hanging and ensured the story would never truly die.
Atherton does not believe a fresh investigation is required now, but he accepts why the issue refuses to fade.
Eight years on from the series in South Africa, there is a fatigue about Sandpapergate in Australia. It is everywhere again: newspapers, podcasts, talk shows. Yet one point still cuts through the noise – the sense, as Atherton puts it, of players not having each other’s backs. That, he feels, is what unsettles the Australian public most and will “rumble on for a while yet.”
Cracks on the field to match the noise off it
All of this lands at a delicate time for the current side.
Australia have just lost 2-1 in South Africa in their first Test series there since the scandal, a symbolic and sobering defeat. Marnus Labuschagne, once a fixture at No 3, has been dropped for the upcoming home Tests against New Zealand after a prolonged slump.
The calendar offers no mercy. After New Zealand, a brutal run looms: a five-Test tour of India, the day-night 150th anniversary Test against England in Melbourne in March, then an away Ashes series in June and July.
Atherton looks at that schedule and sees a squad already straining.
“The schedule is brutal and unforgiving and already there’s cracks in that team,” he said. “It doesn’t feel as though the team is robust enough to get through this period.”
The renewed ball-tampering storm only adds to the strain. “This is adding a little bit more fuel to the fire,” Atherton admitted.
So Australia head into a punishing year with old ghosts back in the room, their culture questioned again, their depth under scrutiny, and their leaders braced for another round of Sandpapergate interrogation.
The bans have long since expired. The reputations, clearly, have not.






