England 131 all out (33.4 overs): Atkinson 29*; Beardman 6-24
Australia: Yet to bat
On a day when Australian cricket was supposed to be answering for old sins, it was England who ended up on trial.
While the sandpaper scandal rumbled on in the background and David Warner and Pat Cummins traded barbs through the TV cameras, a 21-year-old quick from Western Australia walked into the glare of international cricket and tore England apart.
Mahli Beardman, on ODI debut, produced the kind of spell that instantly changes a career. Six wickets for 24. Five of them in his first five overs. England gone for 131 in 33.4 overs, their rebuild towards next year’s World Cup already looking flimsy.
Beardman’s dream debut, England’s familiar nightmare
Beardman needed only two overs to announce himself. Harry Brook, the man England are building around in this new white-ball phase, pushed and nicked off for his first international victim. A simple dismissal, but a telling one. England never really recovered.
The right-armer settled quickly into a nasty rhythm – brisk pace, heavy length, just enough movement – and England’s top and middle order walked straight into it. Tom Banton, one of only three batters to pass 20, drove loosely and followed Brook back. Joe Root, trying to anchor an innings already creaking, was prised out for 17.
Jordan Cox and Sam Curran came and went in the same opening burst. Beardman’s figures at that stage: 5-18 from five overs. On debut. In Perth. By the time he returned to add Liam Dawson and Jofra Archer, he had secured the best ODI debut figures by an Australian.
This was not a freakish collapse on a minefield. It was a fast bowler hitting the deck hard on a lively Perth surface and a batting line-up repeating old mistakes.
Perth pitch, same old story
The WACA – and now Perth’s modern international strip – has long carried a simple message for visiting batters: respect the bounce or pay for it. England ignored it again.
Ben Duckett, Banton and Root, then later Dawson and Archer, all fell driving on the up. Edgy, ambitious strokes against a pitch that demanded discipline. The dismissals were horribly familiar, almost a replay of England’s dismal start to last winter’s Ashes series at the same ground.
Only Gus Atkinson, with an unbeaten 29 from the lower order, showed any real resistance. He shepherded the tail and dragged England past 100, but this was damage limitation, not recovery. No one else built a platform. No one seized the tempo.
Three players passed 20. None passed 30. That tells its own story.
Scandal in the air, opportunity wasted
The backdrop could hardly have been more combustible. The day began with Warner accusing Cummins on Australian television of throwing Usman Khawaja “under the bus” in the latest flare-up around the sandpaper saga. Cummins had already hit back strongly at Khawaja’s comments. Old wounds were open again, the narrative primed for England to twist the knife.
Instead, they handed Australia a release valve.
With the ball still to be bowled in reply, the hosts already hold complete control. The noise around past transgressions will fade quickly if Beardman’s debut becomes the headline and Australia canters to a routine chase.
For England, this collapse drops into an increasingly worrying pattern. Heavy defeats to Pakistan and Sri Lanka last month had already raised alarms about their trajectory in one-day cricket. This was a chance to reset, to show steel in difficult conditions, to push back against a wounded old rival.
They lasted less than 34 overs.
The World Cup is not far away. On this evidence, the real question is no longer about Australia’s scars from 2018, but how quickly England can heal their own.






