logo

Patterson and Konstas Miss Test Selection Opportunity

Kurtis Patterson and Sam Konstas walked into Wednesday with opportunity in front of them and walked off with it slipping through their fingers.

At Cricket Central in Sydney, the New South Wales pair had the stage to push their claims for Marnus Labuschagne’s vacant Test No.3 spot this summer. By stumps, the narrative had shifted elsewhere.

Konstas, Davies light the fuse – then fade

The day began in a blur of blue. After NSW won the toss and batted, Sam Konstas and Ollie Davies tore into South Australia’s attack, ripping 81 from the first nine overs and turning the morning into a one-sided assault.

Wes Agar’s opening over disappeared for 17 as Davies set the tone. Konstas joined in immediately, punching his first two balls through the covers for four. Both openers scored at a tempo more suited to white-ball cricket than a Sheffield Shield arm wrestle.

Davies surged to a half-century from just 36 balls, South Australia scrambling for answers and field changes. The visitors looked rattled. The game felt like it might be decided before lunch.

Then the rush of blood came.

First ball of the 10th over, Konstas charged down the wicket and tried to loft over mid-off. He didn’t clear Nathan McSweeney, the South Australian captain who is himself chasing Labuschagne’s spot. A booming start ended with 24 from 19 balls and a simple catch that cut short a statement innings just as it was forming.

The wicket opened the door for Kurtis Patterson. It slammed shut almost immediately.

Patterson’s golden chance turns into a duck

Jordan Buckingham had already removed Konstas. Three balls into Patterson’s stay, he had the veteran as well.

The 33-year-old, widely viewed as the most natural fit at first drop for Australia, flicked innocuously off his pads and picked out Jake Lehmann at backward square leg. No flourish, no drama, just a soft dismissal and a third-ball duck that will linger in the minds of selectors.

It followed scores of 14 and 9 in the previous Shield round against Tasmania. For a man trying to force his way back into the Test side, the timing could hardly be worse.

Davies kept going, eventually falling to Ben Manenti for 70 before lunch, having been the one constant in an innings that frayed quickly. Nic Maddinson, back in state colours after his surprise international recall and subsequent axing, hammered a brisk 47 after being dropped from the very first ball he faced. It was entertaining, but not the sort of bedrock innings that wins selection debates.

NSW never recovered their early dominance. From 0-81 in a blur, they stumbled to 204 all out before tea. Buckingham finished with his fifth five-wicket haul at first-class level, a powerful return in his first Shield match of the season.

Weatherald responds; McSweeney misses his moment

South Australia’s reply carried its own selection subtext.

Jake Weatherald, recently axed from Test contention, responded in the most convincing way available to a batter: with an unbeaten century. Where NSW’s top order had squandered their platform, Weatherald made his count, batting through the day and steadying a chase that could have wobbled.

McSweeney, though, missed a chance to press his own case. After taking the catch to remove Konstas, he scratched his way to 16 before edging outside off. No disaster, but hardly the sort of innings that screams “pick me” for a Test summer.

South Australia closed on 5-162, firmly in the contest and with Weatherald in command.

Handscomb roars back into the frame

While Patterson and Konstas misfired in Sydney, Peter Handscomb was busy reminding everyone at the MCG that he is far from finished as a Test contender.

The Victorian captain carved out a chanceless 131 not out against Western Australia, an innings built on control and clarity rather than flash. He combined neatly with Ashley Chandrasinghe (53) and Blake Macdonald (74*), steering Victoria to 3-292 at stumps and reasserting himself as one of the most reliable run-makers in the country.

Handscomb had been short of his usual Shield output this season and had endured modest returns on Australia A’s tour of India. He admitted the frustration of feeling in good touch without the numbers to show for it, but said a return to “a couple of basics” had cleared his head and unlocked his best.

He still burns to play Test cricket again and knows that sustained Shield dominance is his only real argument. He did not hide his disagreement with the message sent by Nic Maddinson’s recent recall, but he refused to dwell on it, stressing that his response had to come with the bat.

On this evidence, it has.

Labuschagne’s lean return and Clayton’s opening

Back in Queensland, the man at the centre of all this – Marnus Labuschagne – failed to seize his own chance to quiet the noise.

In his return to domestic cricket, the Bulls captain strode out and crunched the first ball of the day from Beau Webster through the covers for four. It looked like the start of a statement innings.

It wasn’t.

Labuschagne faced 36 balls, found the rope only that once, and nicked off for 12 to a ball angled across him on a sixth-stump line. For a player George Bailey has all but ruled out of the New Zealand series, it was not the forceful rebuttal he might have wanted.

His exit brought Jack Clayton to the crease, a name rapidly moving from left-field mention to serious contender. With a big score in this match, Clayton can push hard to replace Labuschagne at No.3 for Australia this summer.

By the 50-over mark, Queensland sat 2-131, opener Hugo Burdon unbeaten on 64 after notching his second first-class fifty, Clayton 36 not out at the other end. Both would eventually fall – Burdon for 70, Clayton for 52 – as Queensland closed on 5-195, a platform but not a procession.

A race that refuses to settle

One day of Shield cricket rarely settles a selection race. This one certainly didn’t.

Patterson and Konstas walked off with questions hanging over them. Weatherald and Handscomb walked off with runs and renewed relevance. McSweeney and Labuschagne did little to shift the debate. Clayton and Burdon quietly strengthened their cases.

The vacancy at No.3 remains open. The auditions are underway. Who actually grabs it before the summer arrives is still very much in the balance.